3 ms·
Yeah, I think that is extremely likely to lead to subconscious bias. In the good case, you find something worth talking about with that person, and you have a p
by geofft 9y ago
Yeah, I think that is extremely likely to lead to subconscious bias. In the good case, you find something worth talking about with that person, and you have a productive conversation where you go deep onto a topic they should be familiar with and you figure out whether they're actually familiar or not, yes.
In the not-so-good case, you find that they were accused and then cleared of charges for something odious, or that they sued their former employer for entirely justifiable reasons, or that they're an ardent supporter of a political party or religious view you just can't stand, or that they just tweeted that they're pregnant, or whatever.
And even in the good case, you're asking this person something very different from what you're asking other candidates, which means you're likely to be influenced by something as irrelevant as other candidates not having a public record. (e.g., one candidate worked somewhere with an oppressive OSS policy, one didn't, you got to have a good conversation about a project the second candidate's GitHub but did not get as far talking about an internal project the first candidate did.) Which doesn't actually seem that good.
I am incredibly curious to see data, if anyone has it, about who interviews most effectively (in the sense of saying "yes" to candidates that do well, being the one "no" on candidates who left the company quickly, being the one "yes" to candidates whose LinkedIn implies they ended up being successful, etc.) I suspect - but have no data - that asking consistent questions to each candidate leads to higher accuracy. But perhaps you miss out on the rare, extraordinary candidates.
- sokoloff 9y ago> I think that is extremely likely to lead to subconscious bia I agree, but wonder if that process makes the interview more effective rather than less effective overall, bias notwithstanding. It's not like the average unbiased one hour interview has a stellar track record of predicting success, and attempts to create a standardized interview track break down beyond the mid-senior individual contributor or junior manager levels, IME. If I'm interviewing for a Director or VP, I want to have some background information on the candidate to ask specific questions rather than a generic, "Tell me about a time when..." that works at more junior levels.