4 ms·
Isn't, however, this gandparental extended family just the previous gen nuclear family? There is no reason to consider a nuclear family an island onto itself.
by mc32 9y ago
Isn't, however, this gandparental extended family just the previous gen nuclear family?
There is no reason to consider a nuclear family an island onto itself. Extended families are often times, but not always, the linking of multigenerational nuclear families. Now, one can have extended families that are not blood relatives.
But yeah, it is tricky sometimes. If you get shipped off to aunts and uncles or other relatives while mom and dad figs stay together because of issues beyond their control that may not be a nuclear family as it is disruptive to the kids.
- WorldMaker 9y agoI think the context in the article here is "nuclear family [as household unit]", with the elided part in square brackets implied. So there may be no reason in general to consider the nuclear family an island unto itself, but this article is referring to the trend to think of a nuclear family as a household unit (island) unto itself.
- mc32 9y agoA nuclear family as a unit unto itself is most evident when people move to the city or cross country for [reason]. Then you rely on the tendrils offered by modern communication till you establish yourself and begin forming new local relationships. In some settings it may be difficult to do. It can be difficult in the suburbs as elicited in Robert Adams's "New West"[1] and it can also be difficult in the dense cityscapes of Japan[2]. We can dream of the times people were born and died in the same house or village and lived in multigenerational houses out of need rather than will. Today economies are different and the way we organize depends on many things, economic ability, economic forces, culture, etc. Some for the better, others for the worse. [1]http://www.anothermag.com/art-photography/8618/robert-adams-the-new-west http://www.anothermag.com/art-photography/8618/robert-adams-... [2]https://longreads.com/2017/12/01/a-lonely-death-the-extreme-isolation-of-japans-elderly/ https://longreads.com/2017/12/01/a-lonely-death-the-extreme-...