4 ms·
I obviously don't know what's going behind the scenes, but I question the wisdom of ousting someone who makes such a mistake. Constantly pushing the technology
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
I obviously don't know what's going behind the scenes, but I question the wisdom of ousting someone who makes such a mistake.
Constantly pushing the technology/design envelope as Apple does seems prone to the occasional snafu. Having engineers and managers on board that have personally experienced such problems and solved/triaged/otherwise dealt with them seems valuable. Firing them runs the risk of creating a chilling effect toward risk taking, as well as lobotomizing some valuable experience from the company.
Now, maybe the executive was let go because he knew about the antenna problem beforehand, misrepresented its severity to Jobs, and launched the product anyway, in which case, yeah let him go. I recall some speculation that Apple knew about the problem before hand.
But for honest mistakes, with no deception involved, that hurt in the short term but are solvable and no more than a blip in the long term, maybe that's not so wise.
Thoughts?
- mishmash 16y agoYour theory makes sense, but if this is true, he fucked up the iPhone and man, even if letting him stay would create a better executive, increase value to the entire company, etc., I just flat can't see Jobs letting him stay in any manner at all.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoIt is really hard to judge why something like this might have happened. However, I would bet it is related to one of two things: Either he had information (as you mentioned) or his actions after it hit the fan was inexcusable. I can't imagine Jobs being very keen on somebody worrying more about covering his ass than taking care of Apple when things go wrong.
- wazoox 16y agoThe Apple /// came without any fans because Jobs wanted it so, and therefore overheated. In this case, it may be equally difficult to know who's really responsible of what.