5 ms·
It is not transphobic. I find the position of a lot of trans people to be deeply harmful to the rights of cishet women. Claiming my statement is transphobic amo
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
It is not transphobic. I find the position of a lot of trans people to be deeply harmful to the rights of cishet women. Claiming my statement is transphobic amounts to gratuitous mudslinging while simultaneously dismissing the very real challenges faced by cishet women.
I don't mind if you live your life and get your needs met, but I quite resent the way cishet women are getting crapped all over in the process. So, no, I will not reconsider my assertion. To the best of my knowledge, it is completely 100% accurate for biological sex. I see no reason why it should be denied to serve the political agenda of a small subset of people when denying it actively harms people like me when people like me are a much larger percentage of the population.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It is not transphobic. “trans-erasing” would be more strictly accurate of the statement (“transphobic” is often used for all anti-trans discrimination, but it's not really a great generic term.) OTOH, your stated rationale: fear of trans people and the beliefs you associate with them, is precisely transphobic. > I find the position of a lot of trans people to be deeply harmful to the rights of cishet women. And that may or may not be a valid opinion, but that's irrelevant to the fact that claiming that only women can get pregnant is false. > To the best of my knowledge, it is completely 100% accurate for biological sex. Biological sex is multidimensional; the usual way legal gender is initially ascribed is based on presentation of external genitalia at birth, which while it is a biological sex trait and has a correlation with other biological sex traits, is not necessarily aligned with what, if any, functional reproductive capacity exists. The idea that “biological sex” is a unidimensional binary trait is a common but erroneous idea.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAnd all of this erases the very real issues I face as a cishet woman. Being lectured that I need to educate myself on the needs and issues of trans individuals and make tremendous effort to serve their political goals while my needs are trampled under foot and my name is publicly dragged through the mud is no means whatsover to win me over. When trans people can figure out how to speak to their issues without silencing cishet women trying to speak to their own, I will be happy to ally with them. But my experience so far has been that my interactions with people who identify as trans or nonbinary have been completely poisonous. I am fine with supporting their desire to live as they choose. But I am really fed up with their agenda actively harming me and other cishet women. Trans individuals get vastly more friendly, sympathetic support on HN than cishet women do. The idea that I have some obligation to invest more of my time and energy in benefitting them when they have done nothing but actively harm me is deeply offensive to me.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> And all of this erases the very real issues I face as a cishet woman How specifically? What specific issues faced by cishet women are erased by recognizing that becoming pregnant is not uniquely associated with women (cishet or otherwise)?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou have never once spoken to me like you genuinely respect me. Not once. You are on the leaderboard. You routinely talk to me like I am an idiot. Nitpicking the things I say here while never interacting with me as if I have anything of value to bring to the table is actively harmful to my public reputation and seems to be par for the course for how women are treated here. The issues of trans people are different than those of cishet individuals. But trans people act like saying that is somehow othering of them -- unless they are saying it to further their political agenda. There is zero reason anyone should feel compelled to come in here and piss on me for trying to make the point that I believe sexism will also persist. That it is not fundamentally different from racism in that regard. Male to female transexuals face different problems from cishet women. They seem to have a much easier time fitting in on HN than I have had. And as best I can tell it is in part because powerful men can help a transexual and in the process signal that they aren't up to funny business, that it isn't rooted in sexual desire. But an awful lot of powerful men will do not a damn thing for me and I am quite confident that part if the reason is because they fear potential scandal. They fear people will talk because I am a woman. I was quite open on HN about being homeless and having a genetic disorder. No one here feels compelled to do shit all for me to help me resolve my issues. My sob story has completely failed to cause people to take seriously my request for help to figure out how to make money online. I in no way believe your question to be sincere interest in my problems as a cishet woman. Every interaction I have ever had with you suggests to me it is merely a politically correct means to be completely dismissive and contemptuous. So I am going to leave a couple of links here and then, most likely, not engage further. Because the situation here where there is only one woman on the leaderboard of HN and she can get no real support of a sort that will help resolve her financial problems and everyone is completely comfortable with literally watching her starve while standing idly by and then I have to put up with crap like this on top of it -- there just is no polite, politically correct means to reply to that. It is galling and I can't believe people subject me to this and then act like I am somehow the one in the wrong. http://michelerebooted.blogspot.com/2017/11/the-art-of-nonchalance.html http://michelerebooted.blogspot.com/2017/11/the-art-of-nonch... http://michelerebooted.blogspot.com/2017/11/genevieve-traylor-is-fictional-name.html http://michelerebooted.blogspot.com/2017/11/genevieve-traylo... So consider me completely and totally unimpressed with your posturing. You could have kicked a smidgeon of support my way a long time ago instead of being one of the people here actively making my participation on HN more challenging and unwelcoming. Your consistent choice to be a thorn in my side makes your good guy act ring hollow to my ears.