3 ms·
What’s interesting is that on the previous security method - fingerprint - no data was shared with apps. If your face is now a security feature and the data is
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
What’s interesting is that on the previous security method - fingerprint - no data was shared with apps.
If your face is now a security feature and the data is being shared with apps, that sounds like a security leak.
If an app collects your face data, can that data be subpoenaed by a court to attempt to unlock your phone? If a court could work with an outside party to use subpoenaed face data to 3D print your face, could they try to use that to unlock your phone?
I’m satisfied with the fingerprint scanner on my phone. I don’t feel like I need the change in tech. I understand if you’re really concerned about security use a passcode only, but it’s still true that the new face unlock is “differently secure”.
- baddox 9y agoThe thing is, I don’t think the 3D scanner really introduces that much functionality beyond what could be done with any normal front-facing camera and software. I’d bet that a few seconds of normal movement would provide enough parallax to build a decent 3D model. In fact, the Apple APIs may not even use the 3D scanner, given that Animojis apparently work with the scanner covered up (and don’t work in the dark).
- djrogers 9y ago>the Apple APIs may not even use the 3D scanner, given that Animojis apparently work with the scanner covered up (and don’t work in the dark). Animoji uses all of the front sensors - RGB and TrueDepth. From https://www.imore.com/yes-animoji-uses-truedepth-camera-system-iphone-x https://www.imore.com/yes-animoji-uses-truedepth-camera-syst...: > the TrueDepth camera system captures a crude depth mask with the IR system and then, in part using the Neural Engine Block on the A11 Bionic processor, persistently tracks and matches facial movement and expressions with the RGB camera.
- nicky0 9y agoBut face data is not shared with apps for security/unlock purposes. Access to the live face data stream is provided for features like silly Snapchat filters ("turn your face into a lion" type crap) which the user may opt in to.
- acqq 9y agoThe problem is, apparently, the opt in question is "do you want to allow this app to use the camera" not "do you want to allow this app to use your face 3D measurements data."
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoI have a feeling that the average lay user might actually find the camera demand more invasive than 3D measurements. In one they'd feel that the application is getting their picture while in the other just some face contour blah blah.