4 ms·
The core design problem with using the Patriot missile system for ABM applications is that its terminal guidance system fundamentally isn't designed for it. It
by jandrewrogers 9y ago
The core design problem with using the Patriot missile system for ABM applications is that its terminal guidance system fundamentally isn't designed for it. It uses radar for terminal guidance because it was adapted from anti-aircraft applications. That this works at all is impressive, in a "dancing bear" sense, you wouldn't expect the discrimination to be good enough for the purpose.
All purpose-built ABM systems use infrared imagers for terminal guidance with classifiers that pick out both the target and desired point of impact on the target. These are vastly more effective but we also don't sell them to foreign countries AFAIK.
- zkms 9y ago> purpose-built ABM systems use infrared imagers for terminal guidance What kind of optical window for the IR imager gets used for this application?
- jandrewrogers 9y agoThe materials tech is pretty amazing, and they've been building it since the early 90s. At least in the past, they were using sapphire crystals and diamond films that have tiny cooling conduits drilled through them with lasers so that you can run (IIRC) liquid helium through the crystals as a coolant. Even in this configuration, the ablation and thermal loading due to hypersonic transit through the atmosphere has proven to be so high that the optical window is covered in ablative shielding for the first part of the flight, where the terminal guidance package is not much use anyway. Once the missile is within terminal range, the ablative shield is removed and it switches to homing mode. Early tests didn't have the ablation shield, and the damage to the optical window was sufficiently high that the imager lost effectiveness. The performance envelope within atmosphere of the rocket motors they use for ABM is high enough that it really pushes materials engineering to the breaking point.
- killjoywashere 9y ago> sapphire crystals and diamond films that have tiny cooling conduits drilled through them with lasers so that you can run (IIRC) liquid helium through the crystals Citations, pleeeeassse! I neeeeed it!
- joshwa 9y agoA reference to "seeker cryo-cooldown" in this video about a THAAD test: https://youtu.be/0z0l0NsMduQ?t=233 https://youtu.be/0z0l0NsMduQ?t=233
- kijiki 9y agoThat is probably about cooling the sensor. High-sensitivity IR sensors need to be cooled so thermal noise from the sensor itself doesn't wash out a weak IR signal. Fighter aircraft provide liquid nitrogen to captive IR missiles.
- salimmadjd 9y agoIMO, this article is designed to get readers attention with a technical bent, but is used to reinforce the Saudi Lobby position. An interest research that shows the number of times in the past 70 years the NY Times has depicted various Saudi dictator as reformist [0] Indeed, M.B.S. instructed me is the most bizarre choice word by Thomas Friedman in his op-ed [1]. As a writer, I'm so surprised he would even use such a word or the NY Times op-ed editors would actually allow that. BTW, there seem to be an orchestrated media Blitzkrieg to show the new Saudi Ruler. Who is basically follow the same playbook as Saddam Hossein did (eliminating all possible opposition) or Stalin for that matter as a moderate person or country. Saudi Arabia, and other moderate Arab states would also welcome a more engaged U.S. into their backyard [2] Calling Saudi Arabia a "moderate" country is a bit of stretch [0] http://www.jadaliyya.com/Details/34727/Seventy-Years-of-the-New-York-Times-Describing-Saudi-Royals-as-Leading-Reform http://www.jadaliyya.com/Details/34727/Seventy-Years-of-the-... [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/23/opinion/saudi-prince-mbs-arab-spring.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/23/opinion/saudi-prince-mbs-... [2] https://www.brookings.edu/blog/markaz/2017/11/28/how-obama-and-trump-left-a-vacuum-in-the-middle-east/ https://www.brookings.edu/blog/markaz/2017/11/28/how-obama-a...
- fossuser 9y agoThis confuses me a bit, is he not more moderate than his predecessors? They've had some movement on women's rights with ability to drive and run for office. Yes they're still terrible with human rights and they're still killing people in Yemen, but they were doing that before without the current improvement. The NYT article about M.B.S did sound like a general improvement in direction.