4 ms·
From: http://ycombinator.com/rfs3.html http://ycombinator.com/rfs3.html Twitter is important because it’s a new protocol. Fundamentally it’s a messaging protoc
by gojomo 16y ago
From: http://ycombinator.com/rfs3.html http://ycombinator.com/rfs3.html
Twitter is important because it’s a new protocol. Fundamentally it’s a messaging protocol where you don’t specify the recipients. It’s really more of a discovery than an invention; that square was always there in the periodic table of protocols, but no one had quite hit it squarely.
We could try to draw a small excerpt of this 'periodic table':
LONG SHORT
ONE:ONE email im/sms
ONE:PUBLIC blogs twitter
Of course, the axes aren't exact. You can write arbitrarily short emails and blogposts, and lengthy IMs. Twitter is usually 'public' but only viewed by some set of friends/acquaintances/fans, and interactions range from chatty conversations to long lagged correspondences. Each box bleeds into the others with crossover communications.
But you get the idea; the signature modes of each big success are variations on a theme, nailing a new permutation. And it shouldn't be surprising that blogging pioneers happened upon the adjacent twitter opportunity at the right time.
You could build similar tables where an axis-of-contrast is EPHEMERAL/ARCHIVED, or BUSINESS/PLEASURE, or TEXT/AUDIOVISUAL, or REALTIME/TIME-LAGGED, or SIMPLE/POWERFUL, and see some of the same things appear in the quadrants, or other familiar services, or gaping holes -- where there may be Twitter-sized opportunity waiting.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoBlogs existed well before twitter. Blogging also sends messages to nowhere.
- gojomo 16y agoNot guaranteed-short messages, collected in a merged timeline, with interruption (via SMS delivery) as a common/easy option. There is a dimension on which blogging and Twitter are similar. That's why they share a row in the table! But the added constraint, and the possibilities unleashed by that constraint, are a crucial part of Twitter's success.
- zmmmmm 16y agoBlogs themselves aren't short but the RSS feeds for them usually are. Blogs + RSS roughly equals Blog + Twitter with link but for some reason Twitter took over from RSS/Atom.
- mechanical_fish 16y agofor some reason Twitter took over from RSS/Atom Part of the reason is sitting right there in this sentence. You can't even bring yourself to call RSS "RSS", because the so-called "standard" has more forks than the devil's toolshed. But the real reason RSS loses is that it's built on XML, and because nobody actually wants to look at XML a feed is read and written solely by computers, for whose convenience its design has been optimized. Twitter, on the other hand, is a protocol designed to be read and written directly by humans. It excludes all the ugly, verbose, oft-redundant tags and just delivers a message, which may contain an arbitrary number of #hashtags, @addresses, URLs, and blither in whatever order seems appropriate. The result feels human, instead of like the homework from a 1978 class on data processing. And it's really malleable: To invent a new way of Twittering all you have to do is type something and hope that enough of the audience can figure it out.
- zmmmmm 16y ago> But the real reason RSS loses is that it's built on XML, and because nobody actually wants to look at XML a feed is read and written solely by computers, for whose convenience its design has been optimized Not really sure why you say that. RSS was pretty successful for a while - successful enough to get built into every browser and most email clients. End user consumers never saw the XML and the publishing side was usually built into blog software so neither did the publishers. I think this is not so much about XML but rather a more generic notion of simplicity - the whole concept of Twitter is so brain dead simple that it removes nearly all friction in adopting it. It's a much more general simplicity than just the encoding.
- rwmj 16y agoI assumed he was talking about tumblr, which is (I am told) a short, multimedia-rich blog service.
- cmurphycode 16y agoYou're right about Twitter hitting the missing square in the periodic table. I think you glaze over the importance of the short nature of Twitter, though. Yes, you can write arbitrarily short blog posts. But you don't, because you feel like you have an obligation to make your official blog be a well written, safe-for-future-eyes snapshot of your personality. Most of us have started a blog with grand intentions and given up after the effort of crafting essays carefully became too much. Twitter requires no more commitment than a minute of your time. The simplicity of the medium (http://www.flickr.com/photos/jackdorsey/182613360/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/jackdorsey/182613360/) is its greatest strength, and it is also why nobody else was able to make it. It takes a special sort of daring to provide a product that does so little. I'm sure users are constantly clamoring for the 140 character limit to be lifted, for new features to be added, and for more in general. But if Twitter had been created with no emphasis on short, simple messages, it would've been just like all the other blog ecosystems. The impact of the small commitment goes beyond the importance to the average user. I think that one of the huge factors in Twitter's success was all of the hype generated by celebrities. What better way for celebrities to connect with their fans? They can do it in the privacy of their home, it takes nearly zero effort, they get extra points for being tech-savvy, and they cut out the middleman of the media. For the star basketball player who think he's misunderstood (e.g., @TheRealShaq), this is perfect. No more media twisting his words, just one-on-one conversation. Except it's better than one-on-one, because the whole world gets to see how you treat your fans. In short, I think Twitter took off because even though they didn't know it yet, people yearned for a low effort medium of communication.
- gojomo 16y agoAs a fan of oulipo, I totally agree the shortness constraint has powerful positive impacts on Twitter's adoption. It changes how writers write, how readers read, and how groups converse in various permutations. The 'ONE:ONE'/'ONE:MANY' and 'LONG':'SHORT' dimensions are not the only ones in which Twitter colonizes a new part of the possibility space, just the easiest ones to label. (We may need new words to describe all the hybrids of communication styles enabled by Twitter.)
- nazgulnarsil 16y ago"It takes a special sort of daring to provide a product that does so little." I'm hanging on to this one. :)
- msmr 16y agoYou got it! twitter seems to be in just the correct niche (blog/email/sms) AND timeframe (a.k.a. Smartphones & mobile flatrates)
- pandeypunit 16y agoEquality and Access are two important factors behind Twitter success. Unlike Facebook and other social networking platform, I do not need permission from a celebrity to add him as friend, before I can send him message. It also doesn't stop me in following anybody. Without that permission, everyone is at same level. So reiterate, Equality and Access are two important factors behind Twitter success apart from some other points discussed here.