3 ms·
An important difference: gold and diamonds have significant non-financial use. The majority of gold mined each year, for example, goes to jewelry and industrial
by wpietri 9y ago
An important difference: gold and diamonds have significant non-financial use. The majority of gold mined each year, for example, goes to jewelry and industrial use. And the track record for that demand runs back millennia.
- down 9y agogold industrial use is like 10%, jewelry as just a fancier way to store gold, so 90% of gold is so valuable because is valuable, and for so many years, meaning something can be valuable without intrinsic value, aka bitcoin.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoI disagree. Gold is valuable because physical commodities and physical things, like jewelry, etc. tend to track inflation over time. As an investment, gold is terrible. Just look at the chart of gold prices over a long period of time.
- hackinthebochs 9y ago>Gold is valuable because physical commodities and physical things, like jewelry, etc. tend to track inflation over time. I don't know how to read this other than as stating the same thing with different words, i.e. "tracking inflation" is just another way of saying that its valuable.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoWell, what I mean is, physical things tend to track inflation. That doesn't make them great investments. I'm not sure it's fair to assume the same properties for bitcoin, but supposing bitcoin is like gold - gold is actually not a great investment.
- wpietri 9y agoNon-financial use is the majority of gold demand: https://www.statista.com/statistics/299603/gold-demand-by-sector/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/299603/gold-demand-by-se... Jewelry is definitely not just a fancier way to store gold. How many people do you know that sold their wedding rings when prices spiked? I don't think intrinsic value is a meaningful term. Gold has been valued for millennia because it is very useful for making pretty things. And the price has been high for a long time because the supply of it is low.
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoYou've got the causal relationship flipped. Gold isn't valuable because it's used in jewellery. It's used in jewellery because it's considered valuable. There was a time when we hadn't the technology to produce aluminium in significant quantities like we do in today's factories, and it was more expensive than gold. And for that reason, it was used in jewellery, expensive cutlery and even the Washington monument. Gold is mostly valuable for its scarcity and the way our culture has used scarce metals as a store of value, not because of its intrinsic value as a metal. Today we can create artificial scarce tokens digitally, before using a centralised party to manage the ledger, today in a decentralised manner. Who knows whether gold's status will last, or in fact bitcoin's. Perhaps the noble notion of decentralisation won't be valued by markets in the end, perhaps there's no reason to respect one token's value for its scarcity when you can programmatically create a million clones on a single computer. I've been a bitcoin enthusiast for half a decade, but the past few years I've seen a major decline in genuine interest in bitcoin other than as a get rich quick scheme. We used to have lots of cool and fun things going on, now it's bland and boring. People forget bitcoin's only value is its decentralised nature, yet the price increases don't reflect any significant growth in capturing the value of decentralisation, at all.
- vasilipupkin 9y agogold is also used in jewelry because jewelry made out of gold looks good, right? it's not pure scarcity, certain physical properties of it make it attractive, correct?
- joeschmoecad 9y agoYou can make something that looks identical with cheaper alternatives or even synthetic materials. Same with diamonds (see cubic zirconia). Thus, it is not the actual properties that make them desirable as jewelry. It is solely the fact that they are valuable that people want them for jewelry.
- vasilipupkin 9y agohmm, perhaps, but historically you couldn't and so this combination of historical data, etc. as well as physical properties is what gives it value. But, yes, because of the issues you are talking about, going forward we should expect gold to be a bad investment, not a good investment.
- cloakandswagger 9y agoGold isn't worth $1.2K per ounce because of its "non-financial use", and has been valued throughout human history for its scarcity. I'm fairly certain kings weren't making crowns from the stuff 500 years ago because of its conductive properties.
- lucozade 9y agoMostly they were using gold because it doesn't readily tarnish and it's relatively easy to work. Scarcity was necessary, for sure. But definitely not sufficient.
- kgwgk 9y agoBut it was, in large part at least, because of its malleability. There were even scarcer materials that have never been used to make crowns.