3 ms·
It sounds like you're imagining a difference in magnitude, as opposed to a difference in type of motion, you seem to be assuming that I'm suggesting a very larg
by dahart 9y ago
It sounds like you're imagining a difference in magnitude, as opposed to a difference in type of motion, you seem to be assuming that I'm suggesting a very large magnitude. I would call bumping the bottom a type of vertical shaking, if the container is allowed to move vertically, regardless of how far (or short). A vertical shake that moves less than the height of one die doesn't move far enough to allow unpacking, and empirically it works for me. Fast and small vertical shaking, or boiling, if you prefer, will "liquefy" the particles and allow them to settle. Fast and small horizontal shakes would probably do the same, I just speculated above that vertical boiling packs faster than horizontal "tapping", but who knows, I could be wrong, I'd have to do the experiment.
- derefr 9y agoHmm, good point; I wasn't considering <1.0h shakes. (I was mentally considering anything worth being called a "shake" as raising and lowering the entire packed column between the top and bottom of the cylinder, such that it would repeatedly bump both the top and bottom.) A 0.5h shake is indeed effectively equivalent to a Newton's-cradle-like bump.