2 ms·
Users have no expectation of privacy. That’s IT security policy mantra wherever it is legal. Everything a government official does is public at some level. So t
by Spooky23 9y ago
Users have no expectation of privacy. That’s IT security policy mantra wherever it is legal. Everything a government official does is public at some level. So that part of Hunt’s argument is bunk.
From a security point of view, An elected official isn’t some clerk. If she decides to delegate duties to her staff, that’s her decision and responsibility.
I’ve had this argument with people before. IT dogma like this makes life more efficient. In the paper world, guess what? Mail was opened by staff. Time sheets were completed by secretaries. Staff were delegated authority to sign off on stuff up to a threshold. When I started working in IT, my director had a protocol where his secretary could sign off on certain transactions up to a high dollar figure without his presence. Problems weren’t very common.
An IT credential isn’t sacrosanct, and for the 90th percentile executive, there’s no reason to not allow this type of behavior where delegation isn’t possible.
I always thought it was funny when Apple did enterprise briefings, one of their success stories was how a major company wrote an iOS app to allow managers to approve routine bullshit. The quote from some SVP at the client was something like “This app took 3 hours off my workday, and I can eat dinner with my kids.” That’s the ultimate illustration of stupid security culture and the micromanagement it brings along for the ride.
- wastedhours 9y agoI'd argue that's not really brought about by IT security, but by organisational security, e.g. trust. Expense tools were designed for a single, C-Level signatory, because that's what companies requested. "We can't let lower level employees have budget approval". As are a lot of other access arrangements. If enough companies had that workflow (like the director/secretary one you mention).
- dawnbreez 9y ago>where delegation isn’t possible. This is the issue--delegation absolutely is possible in the use cases brought up by MPs and by bystanders. There's not really an excuse when email accounts can be set to auto-forward, and when email delegation accounts exist. Granted, the IT staff should have solved the problem by going to the MP and explaining that email delegation exists, but that's still not an excuse for the MPs to repeatedly break the law.
- cmiles74 9y agoIT credentials should be treated as sacrosanct. Your credentials represent you and are, in many cases, indelibly tied to those credentials. Providing those credentials to others is the most coarse grained method of delegating _all_ of your abilities under that credential. In this case we're talking about pornography and, apparently, rather pedestrian pornography at that. I have no doubt that this will end with people chuckling at each other and that will be the end of it. Should someone mail out state secrets with these credentials the tone of these stories will be very different. This attitude of "sharing credentials makes my job easier" will meet with far less indulgent attitudes. Heads may very well roll and making it more difficult to pinpoint an individual will not be so easily tolerated. Bottom line, sharing the credentials represents very real risk. Perhaps members of parliament do nothing of consequence with their email and that is why this has been allowed to go on for so long.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat argument is bunk. Any competent organization in government protects state secrets with a multi-factor credential that’s protects against reuse, some sort of network isolation, and serious criminal penalties for violation of those rules. Outside of the enterprise, people do this all of the time with limited powers of attorney and other mechanisms. When I had an assistant, I delegated to her the ability to pay my AMEX. If people are commonly sharing credentials, it’s a sign that IT or the business doesn’t have its shit together, just like most random Visa/MasterCard issuing banks don’t with respect to delegation of access.