4 ms·
In all the years I've been doing this the only times I've felt things really gelled and were firing on all cylinders had little to do with methodology and every
by cmrdporcupine 9y ago
In all the years I've been doing this the only times I've felt things really gelled and were firing on all cylinders had little to do with methodology and everything to do with culture and motivation. When people felt cohesive, and they were all working towards the same goal, and that their personal priorities and the project priorities could align.
I do think that the 'agile' methodology focus on short achievable iterations and daily stand up meetings yielded good results _in that context_. Disconnected from a healthy organization or transplanted into a bad one, it just yields epic fail and falls apart.
Another thing that I saw work well was embedding product management, testing, and operations people into small per-project teams with developers, which I found reduced conflict from territoriality and reduced "throwing over the wall" syndrome.
- agumonkey 9y agoFunny how the significant factors are so often implicit and unseen.
- mstade 9y agoIn my soon-to-be 15-year career as a professional software engineer (and several more as an amateur) I've noticed that the common trait of the high functioning teams I have had the distinct pleasure to work with was always the same thing – a great leader. (In one case, there were two, working sort of in tandem.) Trying to sum up these leaders' qualities is difficult, but if I try to distill it I think it comes down to primarily these two aspects: 1. Strong vision and ability to clearly communicate direction 2. Mutual trust They wouldn't tell people what to do, and certainly not how to do it, but they'd always – every single day – point in the direction they wanted you to go and course correct where necessary. It wasn't like it was an all-hands meeting every morning either, it was more like gentle nudging or little reminders, but not unsolicited. It's difficult to explain frankly, but the result was that we as a team never felt unsure as to where we were heading. The most important thing however certainly was the mutual trust. You could trust these leaders to have your backs, no matter what, and these people would trust you to get things done. That sense of trust created an immensely palpable sense of loyalty, you really did feel like your input and efforts mattered, and you always wanted to bring your a-game for the team. Again, difficult to explain, but you know when you're in it. Not one of these teams worked like the other, in terms of methodology, yet things worked and they worked very well. We had issues, for sure, but I've also worked in dysfunctional teams and the same kind of issues in those teams were amplified by terrible leadership, leading to constantly worsening morale and in some unfortunate cases abject failure to deliver.