4 ms·
There's a good chance Disney will win without having to pay off any politicians. In a nutshell: first sale doctrine applies to physical goods, i.e., the DVD pu
by gamblor956 9y ago
There's a good chance Disney will win without having to pay off any politicians.
In a nutshell: first sale doctrine applies to physical goods, i.e., the DVD purchased by Redbox. It doesn't apply to non-tangible goods (specifically, the code that accompanies the DVD) because intangible goods are licensed, not sold. So, Redbox while Redbox can sell the DVDs it purchases without restraint, it has to abide by the terms of the license if it wants to sell the download code.
- kd5bjo 9y agoSo, they can sell the slip of paper that Disney printed the code on, but not the code itself?
- prepend 9y agoI’m not sure why you think that first sale doctrine doesn’t apply to intangible goods. There are some court cases to say it does apply to software, (verner v Autodesk, https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20080522/0016171201.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20080522/0016171201.shtml). Companies definitely want to exempt digital goods from first sale, but there’s no logical reason to do so. Hopefully this case helps establish precedent.
- gamblor956 9y agoThat ruling was overturned because it was simply wrong as a matter of law. Intangible goods are licensed, not sold. Will explain in follow up when I get to a computer. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vernor_v._Autodesk,_Inc https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vernor_v._Autodesk,_Inc. Basically, under US and Western law, an intangible good is only "sold" when all of the relevant right to it are sold. If you only sell copies, you are only selling a right to use the copy, which the law calls a license. (The copy doesn't actually exist, by the way, it's just a legal construct, as downloading actually creates a new set of bits.) Since the license is trivially copied, the owner of the good is allowed to control how the license is used.
- rasz 9y agoHow western is EU? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UsedSoft#ECJ_ruling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UsedSoft#ECJ_ruling But its not applicable in this case, same German court rejected resale of used games on account of identifying them as art and not software.
- rhizome 9y agoIt sounds like you're making the argument that was successful against digital downloads, but I think here there's a case to made that download codes are indeed rivalrous.