4 ms·
> They're not selling any copyrighted material; just the ability to download the material. They're selling codes that the DVD box said "aren't for sale". Wheth
by StavrosK 9y ago
> They're not selling any copyrighted material; just the ability to download the material.
They're selling codes that the DVD box said "aren't for sale". Whether that will hold up in court, I guess we'll see. I don't see why the owner of a thing gets to dictate what I do with the thing after I buy it from them. I bought the DVD with the code, it's mine to resell if I want, even if you didn't want me to when you sold it to me.
- rubyfan 9y agoThe digital download is a license though. They can stipulate that the person with the code bought it with the DVD. Though practically I can’t see how they can enforce it.
- StavrosK 9y agoThey can deny service to the person if they didn't buy it with the DVD, but they can't sue the seller, no?
- rubyfan 9y agoYes they can deny service. It will be interesting if they stick it to the end consumer. They can sue all they want, but I can’t see how they win. The seller here hasn’t broken a law or violated license terms which they would be bound to. I don’t know what’s on the box, but I’d have a hard time believing when I buy a DVD from Walmart that I have entered into an agreement with Disney. When I go to use the code and download the movie, that’s when license terms and conditions and agreement between parties comes into play. But that should be between the holder of the code and Disney. Disney can say the holder must have come across the code by some way Disney likes but this to me is where enforcement gets tricky without implementing some kind of DVD verification or something.
- derefr 9y agoObvious precedent: bulk food items, also usually marked "not for resale." I presume that that wording has no legal impact; I've definitely seen various convenience stores selling the "not for resale" food portions.
- glitcher 9y agoI always thought this had more to do with the fact that bulk items usually don't have nutrition information on them.
- rubyfan 9y agoAnd they are priced differently. The not having nutrition info on it could be a problem for the seller (since you need to have it) but I can’t imagine Costco having a leg to stand on suing the convienence store.
- chipperyman573 9y agoI've heard that's a CYA thing (for the food manufacturers), because a lot of the time the smaller objects won't have legally required nutrition facts on them. If someone resells it, the manufacturer can say "Well we told them not to!" instead of having to argue against a food reseller that they (the manufacturer) have an obligation to print nutrition information on the smaller objects because they (the reseller) assumed the food was eligible for reselling (the manufacturer would probably still win anyway but this cements their victory).
- derefr 9y agoI've noticed that when this (selling "not for resale" items) is done as part of an import business, the importer will print and stick their own nutrition label onto the item. Which doesn't usually add that much more work, because often they're already re-labelling the item to add a translation of the item's name.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoI've noticed that too. Imported stuff at City Shop in Shanghai has Chinese nutrition information stickered over the original English nutrition information. I wish they would have put the sticker anywhere except covering the same information in English. City Shop is specifically targeted at foreigners. That sticker is mostly just preventing me from reading the nutrition info it is purportedly there to provide.