4 ms·
> but includes an emotional component plus time pressure? You don't even need those things. Intelligence and practice will suffice, even for "purely rational a
by throwawayjava 9y ago
> but includes an emotional component plus time pressure?
You don't even need those things. Intelligence and practice will suffice, even for "purely rational arguments".
Defending Truth makes debates easier to win, but isn't a necessary or sufficient condition.
- analog31 9y agoMaybe motivation is a factor too. Debate and negotiation are not games that I anticipate enjoying, whereas spending intelligence and practice on becoming a better musician motivates me. ;-) Also, I suspect that Truth isn't always easy to discern, especially in a world where we're immersed in tradeoffs and complex systems.
- erasemus 9y ago>Debate and negotiation are not games that I anticipate enjoying Yes and I think that's because they entail criticism, which is used to attack ideas and people we don't like. Whereas creating something worthwhile is about discovering or perceiving something already inside the mind that we do like (and therefore cannot seriously attempt to criticize). Building a family is an attempt to create something worthwhile.
- analog31 9y agoI'm reminded of a saying: "It takes a carpenter to build a shed, but a jackass can knock it down."