4 ms·
The best way to preserve Macintosh software from floppy disks
- zeveb 9y agoI'm wondering what the best way to preserve old Mac installations is. I have some old Macintosh computers (one 68K & one PowerPC), and I'd like to get rid of them, but only after I've backed them up and ensured that I can run them on a modern Linux system. SheepShaver is … a bit of a chore to get working (compared to VirtualBox). A quick Googling doesn't reveal any obvious walkthroughs …
- kitsunesoba 9y agoSheepShaver also can’t run everything. Any software that requires graphics acceleration won’t work among other shortcomings. This makes it unusable for a bunch of mid to late 90s Mac games, some of which aren’t available on any other platform. Classic Mac emulation could really use the same quantity and quality of attention that some of the other older platforms have received.
- rjsw 9y agoWhy get rid of them ?
- zeveb 9y agoBecause they're taking up space in my small home, and someday I may want to move. And eventually I'm sure the electronics will fail. Don't capacitors dry out eventually?
- gerdesj 9y agoIf the capacitors come from the right time then they may bulge and have failed already. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_plague https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacitor_plague . Replacing capacitors is generally quite easy and they are cheap. There are lots more things that can go wrong with old electronics and if the chips have lost their logic or whatever, you may find replacing those a bit more of a challenge or even to diagnose. That said, I simply put a new battery into a radio made around 1974 (Roberts) and it worked. I'd already read up on things like tin whiskers growing inside the transistors and all sorts of horrors but I didn't need to dust down my soldering iron. There are a lot of electronics hobby sites around with some very knowledgeable people lurking in them.
- cr0sh 9y agoTin whiskers were really only a thing with lead-free solder that was mandated in a stupid fashion by the EU (I won't go into specifics, but it really didn't make any sense once you started to look into why it was done, and the exemptions, etc). That solder used more tin in the alloy than lead-based solders did, and grew "whiskers" like crazy. Various methods and means were attempted to slow it down (the best way was complete conformal coating - but that made rework very difficult), but it took a while for manufacturers to understand what and how it was happening. I think since then, lead-free solder has a different formulation to make it not as bad, but it still happens. Technically, it can happen in virtually any tin-based alloy, but for some reason lead-based alloys with tin didn't grow them anywhere near as much or as fast. So - a 1974 radio is probably not going to be an issue. The computers, though, are a different thing. It will depend on when they were manufactured vs when the EU directive came around, and when the manufacturer switched over, etc. A lot of small variables come into play. Likely, though, there won't be any problems. I still have computers and electronics from the early 1990s and before that all work fine. The issues with capacitors should be looked at, but it was only a problem for a certain time period (late 1990s IIRC); prior to that you'd only have to worry about "reforming" capacitors if they were very, very old (like power supply caps from a computer of the early 1970s or such). If you had - say - an Altair from the 1970s - yeah, you wouldn't want to try just plugging it in, that could lead to a fire even if the caps looked ok.
- SyneRyder 9y agoIs there any strategy I should use for turning on old electronics that haven't been turned on in a while (or links I should be looking at?) I still have a Commodore 64, Apple IIGS & a Mac LC630, but I haven't turned them on in a few years. For instance, maybe I should plug the devices into an APC UPS, so at least I know it's getting clean power? I'd be sad enough if starting them up caused them to stop working, but I hadn't considered the possibility of them catching fire....
- mrpippy 9y agoI would blow any dust out, and do a basic visual inspection of the logic board before you power it on. Macs of a certain age (like that LC630) have PRAM batteries which may have leaked/exploded, and capacitors which also may have leaked.
- mrpippy 9y agoThe PRAM batteries on old Macs tend to leak/explode, and can make a total mess of the logic board. If you can, pull the batteries out ASAP! The electrolytic capacitors on most late-80s and early 90s Macs also will fail (and probably already have), they leak electrolytic fluid onto the board which can often cause damage. I have several old Macs (SE/30, IIci, Q605, Color Classic) which I had to recap, and often had to fix eaten-away traces as well. The sooner you get them recapped, the better.
- mrpippy 9y agoAssuming you have the disk space, I would get Disk Copy onto your old Mac, and create a read-only image from the contents of your hard disk. (or create a blank image, and copy the contents of your hard disk onto it) Then copy the image to a modern computer, and you can transfer it into an emulator and mount the image. Ethernet to a netatalk or FTP server is usually the easiest way, depending on what kind of Mac it is. If you need advice, PM me or make a thread at 68kmla.org or reddit.com/r/vintageapple
- simmons 9y agoFor what it's worth, I was recently able to recover some Apple IIe/Mac 800K floppies for a relative using a KryoFlux board [1] and a regular PC floppy drive. I was glad to have that option, since I sure don't have any vintage Apple 800K drives lying around! [1] https://www.kryoflux.com/ https://www.kryoflux.com/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cortesoft 9y agoKryoflux is amazing. I have found the best way to get good images is to get a few different old floppy drives (you can find them pretty cheap on amazon or ebay) and take images with a few of them. You will find that each drive has different bad sectors in the images. You can then patch together good sectors from the different drives to create a full, complete image. I was able to get a lot of disk images from disks that were failing to read fully on ANY of the drives, but were failing in different sectors.
- mveety 9y agoSame here. After my Amiga died I wanted to move to emulation, but I found a lot of my disks had died (I had moved to WHDload years before this so they haven't been used in a long time) and I was heart broken. A friend told me about Kryoflux and it worked flawlessly for them. It's only very rarely that I haven't been able to read a disk with it and most of them were super cheap 2000's era shitty disks. It's a utterly lifesaving and magical device.
- earksiinni 9y ago+1 for Kryoflux. I used them to backup all my old Mac floppies. Once you've got the raw images, you can even use an emulator like Mini vMac to use the floppies on your modern hardware. I've done so successfully.
- xenophonf 9y agoI have a small stockpile of 5.25-inch floppies from the early '80s. They're mostly TurboDOS diskettes, which was a multi-user CP/M clone. I have no clue how they might be formatted or even whether they're readable, but I'd love to recover them for admittedly sentimental reasons. Can anyone suggest a starting point?
- bluGill 9y agoHow important is this? I'm guess these are just "it would be neat to see what is there", so that is what I will comment. If you have something that is important look for a professional service - disks this old often have problems and can be only read once. There is a lot of old live music on CD because someone put the cassette tape in an oven and then read it at ultra slow speeds: they got one try as the act of reading the tape destroyed it. Thus for anything important you want someone who knows all the tricks. My first thought is start with an old pc (probably i486) with a floppy drive and a working harddrive, and a network card. Install linux (old kernel - don't give this access to the real internet). From there use networking (nfs or ftp) to copy the parts to a more modern system. Goodwill and surplus stores might still have all the parts if you look around. Also hacker spaces, ask around what someone still has in the dark corners of their basement.
- sp332 9y agoThe Internet Archive is actively looking for and archiving old floppies. http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/5153 http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/5153
- cortesoft 9y agoLook at kryoflux. It can do a sector by sector copy of any type of disk, it is pretty cool. https://www.kryoflux.com/ https://www.kryoflux.com/
- cr0sh 9y agoWell - first you need a known working 5.25-inch floppy drive. These aren't easy to find nowadays; you also need to know what the sides and density the floppies are: Most will be double-sided, and either double-density or high-density; abbreviated DS/DD or DS/HD - but sometimes you'll find for older 5.25 floppies will be Single Sided/Double Density (SS/DD) - there was also a "single sided/single density", but likely your floppies aren't that. Back in the day, many of the "SS/DD" floppies were "DS/DD" manufacturing "rejects" that didn't pass QA quality checks - they sold special punches (or you could DIY it with scissors or a hole punch) to cut the proper notch for the timing hole to allow you to format and use the "other side". This was cheaper than buying the ones that passed (a pack of ten floppies could run $20.00 or more, depending on the brand). If your drive was single sided (meaning it only had one read/write head on one side of the mechanism), you'd have to flip the floppy over (aka - a "flippy"/"flippie") - but then the media would be rotating backwards relative to the "good" side; any dirt that the cleaning wipes on the inside of the main "jacket" in theory could become dislodged and cause problems, but I never encountered that as a kid. But it was a concern at the time. The price difference though made it an acceptable tradeoff. Of course, after getting a working floppy drive, you'd then need a way to hook it up; if you have a motherboard that still has floppy connectors, and you have a cable, then you're one step closer. Otherwise you'll have to use a more complex solution (like the mentioned KryoFlux board). But getting that floppy drive is the first step; if you can, get at least a DS/DD drive minimum; if you can get both a DS/DD and DS/HD drive, that's a good thing too. Otherwise, if all you can find is the DS/HD drives, better than nothing. In theory, a DS/HD drive can read anything (backwards compatible), but in practice by people doing these kinds of recovery, that hasn't always worked out, whereas getting the drive to match the floppy is the better solution. Finding these drives can be problematic, mainly because of a variety of reasons. There's the whole "vintage PC" movement and crowd which have been driving up prices and causing problems with finding the parts, but the greater problem (for virtually anything pre-486) has been manufacturing: Many factories and whatnot used a variety of machine tools which used an "embedded" PC - usually a 286 or 386 - for CNC and similar control work. So finding working floppy drives, not to mention motherboards - has been a pain; as this was becoming known, too, prices have escalated. You'll also probably find that a lot of older PC parts - for some reason, at least on ebay - are being listed out of former Eastern European countries; I am not sure why that is, or how legit it is. You'll also find a lot of stuff from China - again, I don't know the legitimacy of those offers. It may have been one of those "dumping ground" things for PC recyclers here in the USA; if you are based in the USA, it would be best to only look for parts from the USA, alternatively check Craigslist, and local area hamfests for old computer parts.
- nategri 9y agoI'm not sure how close to unobtainium they currently are, but I second the SuperDrive as a viable alternative to something like a Kryoflux. Given you have a 68k or other compatible Mac lying around as well, of course. Ciderpress (windows utility) + SuperDrive-equipped Classic Mac was all I needed for all my early-1980s and Macintosh and Apple ][ related hobby adventures. EDIT: Well I guess if you're stepping all the way down to 140KB ProDOS disks you'll need access to an Apple ][ system that can bridge the gap. Apple ][GS's are great for this.
- re 9y agoSite appears to be down at the moment; it's in the Internet Archive though: http://web.archive.org/web/20171204210040/vintageapplemac.com/155-the-best-way-to-preserve-macintosh-software-from-floppy-disks http://web.archive.org/web/20171204210040/vintageapplemac.co...