3 ms·
Patents are broken in implementation, not as a concept.
by gaius 16y ago
Patents are broken in implementation, not as a concept.
- nova 16y agoMaybe a non-broken implementation is not possible.
- gaius 16y agoIt is if you can first solve the problem of getting people with domain knowledge to work as patent clerks, or if there is a "peer review" process or something. The alternative to patents is not "all information wants to be free", it's paranoid secrecy. If people are to invest in R&D, they need protection from copycats. I mean, check this out: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/07/business/07muffin.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/07/business/07muffin.html
- kiba 16y agoThe alternative to patents is not "all information wants to be free", it's paranoid secrecy. If people are to invest in R&D, they need protection from copycats. I mean, check this out: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/07/business/07muffin.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/07/business/07muffin.html The other alternative is that people get along with openness just fine. Beside, people don't have an inherent right to a technological secret, at least in the normal cases.
- gaius 16y agoYou are making the same economic mistake that a lot of anti-IP types do, which is that you assume that the cost of duplicating a thing has any relation to the cost of producing it in the first place. It does if you're talking about, I dunno, spoons. The point of patents is, if you discover a method of doing something, you patent it, and if anyone wants to use your process, they pay you to license it. So we provide a mechanism - but not the guarantee, since no-one might be interested - for a return on an investment into R&D. Do you really, honestly believe that a drug company would research a new drug, spend a decade shepherding it through clinical trials and FDA approval (we are talking an investment of hundreds of millions of dollars) and then a generic manufacturer sells it for a little over the price of the raw materials, having gotten all the hard work done for them for free? Because even if they wanted to they couldn't; they'd be bankrupt.
- gnaritas 16y ago> The point of patents is, if you discover a method of doing something, you patent it, and if anyone wants to use your process, they pay you to license it. So we provide a mechanism - but not the guarantee, since no-one might be interested - for a return on an investment into R&D. That is not the point of the patent system, that is the means by which the actual goal is obtained. The goal of the patent system is make the information public so all of mankind can benefit from it and the knowledge doesn't die with the inventor. Buying off the inventor with a limited monopoly on the idea is merely a means to an end.
- gaius 16y agoThe goal of the patent system is make the information public so all of mankind can benefit from it and the knowledge doesn't die with the inventor If you have a mechanism other than patents that makes it economically possible for private organizations to engage in capital-intensive R&D and make the information public, let's hear it.
- gnaritas 16y agoWhere exactly did I imply that? I was merely pointing out the motivations of the patent system. The system is not necessary for companies to be economically viable as they've been doing that with trade secrets long before patents were around. The patent system was meant to unlock those trade secrets for the benefit of the public, it was never about the inventor's best interests.
- kiba 16y agoYou are making the same economic mistake that a lot of anti-IP types do, which is that you assume that the cost of duplicating a thing has any relation to the cost of producing it in the first place. It does if you're talking about, I dunno, spoons. I have made no such claim. In any case, producing in the first place will cost an order of magnitude more than copying. However, this seem to be of little hindrance in the observations that I been able to make over the years.
- kam 16y agoParanoid secrecy probably costs more to maintain than the benefit they receive from it. Their secret isn't much of a competitive advantage. Their brand is. Keep trademark, kill patents. > "Some bakery experts were skeptical about Bimbo’s claims of top-secret processes, saying the mythology surrounding Thomas’ muffins was more about smart product branding than proprietary baking. The basic techniques for making an English muffin were widely known, they said: English muffin dough is very watery and when it is cooked at high heat the water evaporates quickly and leaves large air pockets."
- akeefer 16y agoI agree, but what's the chance that we'll ever get a non-broken implementation? If someone really tries to fix it, that would be great, but what are the odds it'll really be fixed instead of just being broken in different ways? From my perspective, ExpectedChanceOfBrokenness * ExpectedCostOfBrokenness > ExpectedCostOfKillingThem . . . so the probabilistically optimal course is to just kill patents for software (and business methods), even if it's not the absolutely optimal course.
- kiba 16y agoSometime, you don't fix what's not broken. Patents are probably a solution to a non-existent problem that everyone assume to exists.
- krakensden 16y agoI think it might be more accurate to say the legal system is broken, because that's what makes patents so dangerous. You can't afford to participate in the legal system unless you have lots of money, and patents are just one way incumbent companies can force their competitors into litigation.
- kjrose 16y agoThis is true about many ideals. See socialist, laissez-faire capitalist, and communist supporters for arguing points. Hell, see any utopian idealistic system. The excuse is the implementation always fails. How many times does implementation have to fail before we start to question whether it is simply possible to implement it correctly and whether it's worth the cost and frustration in the first place?