3 ms·
The word socialist has a variety of connotations in the U.S. For instance to a segment of the U.S. population having universal healthcare is equated with socia
by yequalsx 9y ago
The word socialist has a variety of connotations in the U.S. For instance to a segment of the U.S. population having universal healthcare is equated with socialism. Capitalists in France, Great Britain, Denmark, Germany etc. tend disagree with this equating. So when someone says, “Not true socialism” we need to know if they are referring the actual definition of socialism or the popularly bastardized colloquial meaning.
What is for sure true is that power corrupts and concentrating too much in too few hands is bad. Ignorant people like Chavez and Maduro who have simplistic ideas and too much power is really, really bad. Think Mao and Pol Pot.
When the cause becomes more important than the truth, whether it be communism, environmentalism, religion, free markets, etc., then people will suffer if policies are implemented simply to support the cause.
Just saying, “Socialsim is bad” is not helpful because then all one has to do is paint a particular policy as being socialistic to be defeated. There are countries that have what many Americans would call socialist policies that do great. Some do not.
- mmirate 9y agoBut how do we know that western Europe is doing well because of the welfare systems that their capitalist economies prop-up? How do we know it isn't the opposite; that western Europe would do better if its highly effective capitalist economies didn't each have to prop-up a welfare system?
- yequalsx 9y agoMy comment was about how socialism has different connotations to different people. That capitalists in America decry universal healthcare as socialist and capitalists in Europe tend not to. Just labeling capitalism as good or bad is not helpful. Aspects are good. Aspects are bad. Same with socialism.