3 ms·
This is very theoretical. Like if you send a platoon to get into some taliban fighter’s home and execute him in front of his kids it’s a war crime, but if inst
by cm2187 9y ago
This is very theoretical.
Like if you send a platoon to get into some taliban fighter’s home and execute him in front of his kids it’s a war crime, but if instead you just flatten the house with a bomb it’s not. Well in option 1 the kids get to live, I’d argue it’s preferable to option 2.
- EliRivers 9y agoWhat if, when you captured this soldier, that apparently this platoon of yours can do, you just didn't summarily execute him? That's really my suggestion. Try to not murder people, when you have that option. As opposed to the OP option of summary execution of captured soldiers. I don't see that this is theoretical. We watched this play out in practice for many years. Turns out that running around executing people really doesn't help. Or maybe we just didn't do it enough? We do seem to be well beyond the point of listening to reality nowadays; maybe we just need to shout ideology louder. Like ISIS.
- cm2187 9y agoI am not convinced ISIS will be defeated by inviting their fighters to a polite debate where we will attempt to convince them of the error of their ways.
- philipov 9y agoWith bastions of egalitarian democracy like the US, who needs tyrants?
- monocasa 9y agoYou're not trying to convince current ISIS soldiers, but instead the potential future members of their ranks that are being inundated with propaganda about how hypocritical American policy is. Winning ultimately will be more about drying up their sources for new recruits so that a war of attrition has some effect.
- wfo 9y agoWell with option 1, you create a whole family of terrorists who will (with some justification) hate and try to destroy the United States for the rest of their lives which will later become the justification for endless war, so if you're someone who profits from or enjoys war and death and misery it sounds pretty good I suppose.