4 ms·
Unless the US has declared war on itself, the capture of an American POW by the US seems contradictory in principle, and should make any American at least a bit
by krapp 9y ago
Unless the US has declared war on itself, the capture of an American POW by the US seems contradictory in principle, and should make any American at least a bit uncomfortable.
If it's difficult to consider whether or not the rules of war apply in this case, then maybe that's because the war being waged is unjust in its scope or fraudulent in its definition.
- maxerickson 9y agoThere's no contradiction of principle, a US citizen can fight against the US in a war without the US having declared war on that individual. It's happened, some number of US citizens fought for Germany and Japan in World War 2 (and paranoia about it lead to the Japanese internment camps).
- zipwitch 9y agoOne driver for American internment camps for Japanese citizens appears to have been the actions of several Americans of Japanese descent immediately after Pearl Harbor - the Niihau incident: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niihau_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niihau_incident
- IncRnd 9y agoThe reason there are detainees and enemy combatants in addition to POWs is that a POW is someone who was fighting under the banner of another state. If the person isn't wearing a uniform or if they fight for a group that isn't recognized as a state, they are not generally a POW. "Rules of war" apply to POWs in this system.
- maxerickson 9y agoBoy that sure would be messy if we ever ended up waging war on a series of nebulous non state actors.
- IncRnd 9y agoExactly the point!