5 ms·
Children are a resource that creates our future. It would be super nice if society stopped acting like investing in our children is a waste of resources while w
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Children are a resource that creates our future. It would be super nice if society stopped acting like investing in our children is a waste of resources while wondering why the world is going to hell.
- ggg9990 9y agoInvesting in children isn't a waste but getting a graduate degree to do it is.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI homeschooled my 2xe sons. I served as Director of Community Life for the TAG Project for a time. This was support for my ability to homeschool my kids in a situation where no school, public or private, was qualified to adequately accommodate them at both ends of the spectrum at the same time, which was what they needed. My oldest has two conditions which can each lead to a neurotic relationship to food severe enough to require in patient intervention. He has a healthy relationship to food because of my approach to handling his issues. There are an awful lot of things that can go wrong in a child's life that can potentially lead to a need for enormous resources at state expense from medical to mental health to behavioral, which can go very differently if there is a sufficiently knowledgeable full time parent to handle it before it goes so very wrong. You are in error. More education is not wasted on raising kids. Your opinion sounds incredibly ignorant to me.
- abalashov 9y agoIt also sounds ignorant and ill-considered to me. What baffles me is the amount of people in the US, usually in parochial cultural settings, who lack significant formal education or pedagogical background and are nevertheless deemed fit to home-school their kids. How is this legally possible? Now can a high school drop-out single mom (absent some extraordinary characteristics) possibly provide a well-rounded and adequate curriculum in a variety of general education subjects, ranging from math to literature, to world history, to biology? If anything, the problem is that there aren’t nearly enough PhDs teaching kids.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoThe online high schools these days are varied and pretty good. If you have a child with special needs or just doesn’t fit into the box the public education system is designed around then homeschooling is the best option. You don’t need a PhD to teach grammar to an 8 year old. There’s also a wealth of incredible videos and teaching materials to help too. If anything I think parents are best suited to teach their own children until high school given the parents have a reasonable IQ.
- abalashov 9y agoYes, but a certain level of literacy, cultural development and education is still required on the part of the parent in order to make effective use of all those resources. One still has to make sensible judgments about how to appropriate them and to supplement them with intelligent pedagogy. Doubtless, some parents who home-school their parents have an adequate foundation for this. However, some of the greatest proponents of home-schooling I've met most definitely do not, and it boggles my mind.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoThis is true. I’ve seen it. I’m not sure this is such a bad thing. I know this sounds crazy but I kinda want to see how this plays out. Maybe some education diversity will have positive impacts we can’t forsee
- abalashov 9y agoMayhaps. But based on the trends I've seen to predominate in the world of "education diversity", I wouldn't bet on it...
- abalashov 9y agoFor reasons better addressed in PG's timeless "Nerds" article (http://paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://paulgraham.com/nerds.html) better than in most other places, I don't think many children, least of all intelligent children, really "fit" into the box of public school. But that's part of the point, as I see it. Lots of modern institutions are a bit unnatural and require some contortion for humans to squeeze themselves into. Public school is valuable in teaching that, or at least it was to me and many other people I know, as we reflect upon it years later.
- abalashov 9y agoSo, ideally children should be taught about life and how the world works, helped with homework, and/or home-schooled by people with little to no formal postsecondary education? Seriously?