3 ms·
As effective evidence goes, a blog is exactly the same as a HN comment but with no voting system. It is a single person opinion, some which I would agree to and
by belorn 9y ago
As effective evidence goes, a blog is exactly the same as a HN comment but with no voting system. It is a single person opinion, some which I would agree to and some which I disagree with.
To counter some of the arguments in there. Men in general has smaller social network. Where the blog argues that friends and relatives are much more concerned about a woman being out on the street because women tend to have a much harder time on the street, the fact found from medical research and statistics is that those friends and relatives simply are not available to the same extent for men. Men at the bottom of society don't generally have a social support network where they can ask for help.
The blog claims that women tend to make less money than men when homeless. No they don't. Data on begging finds that society is the most generous when it comes to young women, and among people who beg in the street they are the highest earners. "able bodied men", refer to the abusive tactics of exploiting desperate people into dangerous low paying temporary jobs, sometimes illegal, and can be about as healthy as selling sex on the street. Its a common tactic heard from paperless which are bounced between illegal construction sites, sometimes sold like cattle.
The blogs claims that men choose to become homeless and women do not. That is victim blaming. No one choose to be at the bottom of the social ladder.
The blog briefly touch on the subject that society sometimes welcome women, even homeless and without any wealth or status to their name. As the blog points out this is mostly to do with sex, but what it miss is that comes from the cultural values in dating. Women are not primarily judged based on how much money they have, so homelessness is not as dooming factor as it is for men. Cultural values make it so that fewer women would ever consider dating a homeless man compared to the number of men who would consider dating a homeless woman.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe blogs claims that men choose to become homeless and women do not. That is victim blaming. No one choose to be at the bottom of the social ladder. I have no idea how you are getting that from the post at all. I also get really tired of being accused of victim blaming for trying to address complex subjects with a bit of nuance. It begins to feel to me like a cheap shot hurled by people who don't actually have a good rebuttal, so they figure mudslinging will suffice. The point is not that men choose homelessness and women do not. The point is that choices made at the bottom of the social ladder are made within a particular context and this context varies some in part based on gender. Men and women make different choices in part because they are faced with different choices. I happen to be the author of that piece. In addition to firsthand experience with homelessness, I had a college class on the subject many years before spending some time homeless. I didn't give you the link to imply that a blog post somehow is more authoritative than me commenting on HN. Since I wrote it, it is exactly like if I wrote a long comment here, only it has already been previously written and that has certain advantages, like saving me time and, hopefully, having fewer typos and being perhaps a little more thoughtful because I had time to think through what I wished to say. Your rebuttal about social networks strikes me as essentially a different way to make the same point. Poor men simply lack the option of staying with friends or family that so often keeps women from being literally on the street. Framing it as a rebuttal sounds intentionally and unnecessarily fighty.
- belorn 9y agoIf you have no money, no status, no social support to ask for help, then being on the street is not a choice. I took the "Men have more freedom of choice than women" as to mean there was a choice, especially with the "men are more empowered" part. It sounded like blaming men for choosing to be poor as if their gender would somehow give them a choice to not be at the bottom. If that’s not your intention then it wasn't. I personally support the view that social safety nets should exist to prevent homelessness, largely because I believe that in the general case homelessness is not an active choice but rather a situation caused by circumstances. Social support network is commonly used in medical research. The gender difference are seen in all levels of society, from rich to poor, and as such is not the same as the point you bring that friends or family are more likely to help a woman in need. Data on the size of social network (number of friends, contact with family and children, friend of a friend distance) is different for women and men. If all that was different was the rate that family and friend would offer help, then those numbers should be identical. According to some research, the difference in life expectancy between men and women are partially caused by the difference of social support during the elderly years. The cause of that in turn is generally blamed on gender roles and social expectations, where men are expected to prioritize work over building family and social ties and women expected to do the opposite.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWell, the primary point of the piece is that I was a woman on the street and, in some sense, it was a choice for me because I had been offered a place to stay on more than one occasion. In some cases, it was pretty clear that I would be trading sex for a place to say. I turned down those offers. All people make choices, even very poor people who are faced with nothing but bad options. In such a situation, the best you can do is try to choose the lesser evil. But it is really disingenuous and dehumanizing to act like homeless people make no choices whatsoever.
- belorn 9y agoIndividuals naturally make choices, including when there are just bad options. The point of social safety nets is to make sure that there will be a good option, which would then make it a choice between a good option and several bad ones, which arguable make it to no longer be a choice. Talking about choices when all options are bad sounds like the wrong word. Naturally choosing the best option is good, but a bad option is still bad. Similarly talking about being empowered to pick the best option between an multitude of bad options sounds wrong. It might be correct when talking about a individual person, and from the sound of your comment it sounds like you made decisions based on your own values even when it cost you a place to stay, and that is strong.