5 ms·
It's sad that there seems to be little internal critique coming from within universities of the complete takeover of schools by administrators. When it does hap
by dmix 9y ago
It's sad that there seems to be little internal critique coming from within universities of the complete takeover of schools by administrators. When it does happen it's almost entirely the result of some external rumblings or a direct affront like this being twisted.
I guess it's because these same administrators ultimately control the narratives (and budgets, jobs, etc) coming from the schools, creating a self-protecting cycle which only generates more administrative power.
So when attempts to curtail their power happen they can twist it to make it seem like it's an attack on teachers, students, and research - instead of the separate group of people who consume the greatest amount of resources within the school, who don't generate the positive research and economic utility for which universities are typically known.
Which is a shame, because there are probably no better people to stand up for this than the professors and researchers. Plenty of research has shown these people and their work aren't responsible for the massive increase in tuition and costs associated with schools. Yet the problem is perpetually the amount of revenue and income the school can make, not how it's being used.
- chasil 9y agoU.S. university students who feel that they are getting a bad deal should go to Europe. http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32821678 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32821678 Think twice about beginning a bachelor, masters, or doctoral degree in this country, as you will be crushed with debt. With a lot of work, I was able to graduate in '94 with an E.E. degree with a total student loan debt of $1,500. That is not possible here anymore, but it is possible in Europe. If I had to do it again, I would be gone.
- rxhernandez 9y agoI was able to graduate with an EE degree, within the past five years and with no debt at Cal Poly (a university with one of the highest ROI on the west coast). <$7000/year is certainly doable if you're living at home with your parents.
- chasil 9y agoTo be honest, I spent a year living at home, but my college of engineering was 60 miles away. I lived near campus otherwise.
- woodson 9y agoWith the new tax regulation, as a U.S. citizen, do you have to pay taxes on tuition and stipends you receive when you do a Ph.D. overseas? (I'd assume so, since overseas income is taxable AFAIK, but I don't really know what the situation is).
- danzig13 9y agoTuition would be much lower, I think you are credited for the taxes you would pay in country, and generally - while you have to report foreign income - you have to make quite a bit before tax would be assessed.
- throwawayjava 9y agoI thought it was "only" $100,000? Seems like a lot of engineering types would be close to that limit.
- danzig13 9y agoFor a job after university probably, but I meant to speak to a tuition waiver at a foreign university. I doubt tuition waiver plus stipend would approach that in most other countries. Even for the job scenario, you get a tax credit for foreign taxes paid which in most industialized countries would probably neutralize any US tax burden and then some. If the job is in a developing country, I would think the cost of living advantages would make it worth it if you were above the limit. However, not a CPA or finance pro. I went to grad school abroad and looked into the implications of staying a bit.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> It's sad that there seems to be little internal critique coming from within universities of the complete takeover of schools by administrators This is just patently false. The criticism of admin bloat by faculty and students precedes the right-wing press criticism by decades, is far more harsh, and is still going strong. The whole damn criticism, as it exists in the popular press today, can be traced quite directly back to academia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benjamin_Ginsberg_(political_scientist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benjamin_Ginsberg_(political_s... Or a more recent example, https://home.isi.org/sites/default/files/MA59.3_Seery_SymposiumEssay.pdf https://home.isi.org/sites/default/files/MA59.3_Seery_Sympos... And from the student perspective, the recent votes at places like Chicago to unionize (and, more importantly, the justification provided by the student groups that organized those votes) Far from complicit, faculty and students are leading the charge, and have been since the 1980s. BTW, if you wanted to curtail administrative bloat/power in universities, there are ways to use the tax code and science funding policy to do so. and lots of serious policy proposals by the people listed above would very likely have great effect. This policy targets students instead.
- theptip 9y ago> BTW, if you wanted to curtail administrative bloat/power in universities, there are ways to use the tax code and science funding policy to do so. Can you give a summary of your proposals here? Skimmed the Seery article and it doesn't seem to have anything directly related to the tax code, but could be missing it.
- 4bpp 9y ago> And from the student perspective, the recent votes at places like Chicago to unionize (and, more importantly, the justification provided by the student groups that organized those votes) I'm at a school that underwent a grad student unionisation drive, and pretty much everything that the union proposed would have amounted to further empowering the administration at the expense of the academics (e.g. introducing new mediator officials with extensive compulsive power over advisors if their students should feel wronged in one way or another, hiring more staff to enforce diversity-friendly admissions and hiring outcomes, ...). At least the politicised end of the student body seems to consider the administration, rather than the academics, to be their natural ally.
- ikeyany 9y ago> It's sad that there seems to be little internal critique coming from within universities of the complete takeover of schools by administrators. According to the White House, everything in the executive branch is going wonderfully.