3 ms·
This person is not claiming to know a cause: this person is claiming that there is another hypothesis that you can conceive "in a moment with zero effort" that
by saurik 9y ago
This person is not claiming to know a cause: this person is claiming that there is another hypothesis that you can conceive "in a moment with zero effort" that this study design was incpaable of isolating.
There are multiple reasons that could have happened: one is that the scientists didn't think of it (which to me would undermine their credibility as it is really obvious as a possibility), a second is that this study was much cheaper and they weren't sure there would be a correlation at all (so now there is enough evidence to warrant a better study), and a third is that they didn't care about "why" and were only interested in "that".
To the scientist's credit, the article quotes them as saying that they don't know the cause, which is great, and they say "too early" so they might intend to keep going. To their discredit, they gave enough of an explanation based on stuff they weren't sure of to the reporter to guide it to the point where the headline is just guesswork, not real science.
On the other hand, you certainly... and apparently the scientists :/... are simply assuming your explanation and then using a study that is incapable of discerning the the difference between these two hypotheses to dismiss the idea, which is clearly not OK.
[I am sorry if someone saw a draft of this comment or if it appeared under the wrong parent for a moment: I was having issues replying on my iPhone today :/.]
- SubiculumCode 9y agoIn my own work, reporters of my research off end up bending thing to say something kind of stupid, and definitely not what I had said.