3 ms·
Being a "threat to speech" is irrelevant - what matters is the law, specifically the First Amendment, and that imposes restrictions on government and its offici
by icebraining 9y ago
Being a "threat to speech" is irrelevant - what matters is the law, specifically the First Amendment, and that imposes restrictions on government and its officials that it doesn't on private individuals and companies.
As for Hillary, the point is that RogerStone can no longer receive her messages (and directly comment them) and tag her on his Tweets to others. If she doesn't want to listen to him, she still can mute him, but blocking imposes restrictions on his speech.
- mc32 9y agoWhat happens when those companies become an oligopoly or monopoly on speech? What if the gov't uses twitter as it's only diffusion platform and what if them Twitter suspends say US EPA or Education twitter handles because they violate "ToS"? Since people can't in that case comms with gov't orgs, does that encumber free speech?
- icebraining 9y agoDoes that encumber free speech? Maybe. Is it illegal? I don't think so. If the government can't communicate because it only uses Twitter, then I think the answer is "don't do that". The government can always use its own means of communication.
- mc32 9y agoCertainly they could revert to phone and snail mail, which was the prev status quo. However, that would be to the detriment of the people.
- icebraining 9y agoOr they can host their own sites...
- mc32 9y agoThey could also roll their own "Twitter" like microblogging service... But I don't think we'd consider that a solution.
- krapp 9y agoActually... that sounds like a good idea to me. Except for the part where no one would pay attention to it because it's Twitter, and the part where the government controls the platform, making internal surveillance and censorship inevitable. It would probably just wind up a PR machine for the party in power. But government employees, from the President all the way down to, say, interns having an official and direct means of communication with the people, on public record? I'm all for it.
- libertyEQ 9y agoThis is what I was thinking. If the Trump org started their own Mastodon instance and syndicated it to Twitter/FB using their APIs, I wonder what might happen. They'd have to restrict signups, but if they provided a read-only, http version (cached) that could be interesting.