8 ms·
The destruction of graduate education in the United States
- corporateguy5 9y agoAcademia in stem fields has devolved in most cases to a backdoor for immigration into the United States. Students serve as cheap labor for tenured professors, where they produce no real new scientific understanding. Schools use the students, students use them to immigrate to the United States. Modern academia is a farce except for the very upper echelons of the top institutions. Whether you agree with leftist thinking or not, academia is heavily politically biased to the left, therefore divorcing itself from the objectivity that rigorous academic study makes claims to espouse.
- saboot 9y ago> Students serve as cheap labor for tenured professors, where they produce no real new scientific understanding No evidence for this whatsoever. Maybe your graduate experience wasn't great, but this is a very hyperbolic and inaccurate statement. Graduate education is what you put into it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- orf 9y agoWhat a load of uncorroborated rubbish. > Whether you agree with leftist thinking or not, academia is heavily politically biased to the left Reality is heavily biased to the left, or at least certainly the USA's version of the left (which is really more centralist). It should tell you something when institutions inhabited by some of the most intelligent people on the planet, producing some of the most ground breaking scientific work in the history of mankind all lean a certain way. And hint: the way they lean doesn't espouse that God created the world and climate change is a fallacy. Funny that, isn't it.
- simula67 9y ago> Reality is heavily biased to the left, or at least certainly the USA's version of the left (which is really more centralist). From what I can see, it is not. > It should tell you something when institutions inhabited by some of the most intelligent people on the planet, producing some of the most ground breaking scientific work in the history of mankind all lean a certain way. It tells me that OPs assessment is correct. Universities in the USA have become left wing indoctrination centers > climate change is a fallacy The left has it's own problems with science : http://reason.com/reasontv/2016/07/15/are-republicans-or-democrats-more-anti-s http://reason.com/reasontv/2016/07/15/are-republicans-or-dem...
- orf 9y ago> From what I can see, it is not. Ok, cool, doesn't change reality though does it. > Universities in the USA have become left wing indoctrination centers Strange how places where you meet people from diverse backgrounds, cultures and countries while expanding your knowledge makes people more tolerant isn't it. > The left has it's own problems with science... "Reason.com: Free Minds and Free Markets" hahaha ok. Trickle down economics Right wing Christianity Guns make people safer, who needs mental healthcare funding when you have them Trump Climate change isn't real! These oil companies assured me. Transgender people can go to hell Bootstraps not included. Hey look at these brown people, not the blatent wage theft, tax doging and gorging we are doing! Hardcore gerrymandering (admittedly not entirely partisan) The southern strategy. Give me a break. Feel free to argue that any of those are liberal issues by the way, I have a feeling you won't.
- digitaltrees 9y agoEconomic reality does. Want to compare the predictions of Paul Krugman, Joesph Stigltz, Ben Bernacke to Aurther Laffer, Larry Kudlow etc? How about all the warnings that Gov Browns tax increase in California would decimate the economy while Gov Brownbacks tax cut in Kansas would trigger unimaginable growth. What really happened. Facts please. As far as universities. The left accepts the scientific method. The right says that goes against god. University aren’t indoctrinating anyone. People are self selecting where they want to be.
- nooron 9y agoYes! All those pesky foreign Germans and Jews, using STEM as a backdoor to get into our society. What do any of them do? Math? Some nonsense about atoms? Those foreigners are very different from us and will never assimilate, and they certainly won't contribute to our economy, knowledge or international stature.
- leereeves 9y agoWhy wouldn't the obvious solution work? Raise graduate student stipends to cover the tax.
- munin 9y agoThe money doesn't exist to do that. Graduate student stipends are paid out of government grants, and the amount of money issued by the government as grants is going down.
- leereeves 9y agoThey could make it grant-neutral by lowering the tuition rates at the same time. The universities would receive less money but it need not be "the destruction of graduate education".
- munin 9y agoThe university is using that money for something already, and now it isn't. I guess this depends on what that something is. If they're just stuffing it under their mattresses or using it to pay some associate under provost for squirrel education a $150k salary, or putting marble plating in the athlete dorms, then this probably isn't a big loss. If it's going to something like students with disabilities or need based scholarships...
- leereeves 9y agoIt's only a bit of an exaggeration to say that a lot of money is used to "pay some associate under provost for squirrel education a $150k salary, or put marble plating in the athlete dorms". Surely the universities could find some expenses to cut that wouldn't hurt too much.
- munin 9y agoMaybe! You'd have to look at the numbers. I remember the last time someone showed me numbers, actually most of the money went into core operations cost to offset money that the state used to contribute. Though I think in this particular case, for my particular institution, the University could totally mitigate all financial cost to graduate students by cutting the subsidy the University gives to the athletics programs (about 15% of the athletics budget is paid for by the students in the form of fees the students are assessed on top of their tuition).
- MollyR 9y agoWhen some of endowments for many universities are in the millions and Harvard has an endowment of 37.5 billion, I find it hard to have sympathy towards this. The colleges and universities have become corporations that run on student loans and graduate student slave labor. This has to change, and it will be a painful process no matter what happens. https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-list-college/articles/2017-09-28/10-universities-with-the-biggest-endowments https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-lis...
- mikeash 9y agoIs massively raising taxes on graduate students actually going to help matters?
- blfr 9y agoCouldn't the universities just appropriately price the graduate school tuition instead of pretending it's worth tens of thousands of dollars a year and then giving it away for free?
- wsxcde 9y agoThe article responds to your argument. Might be a good idea to read it first.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoHi, please don't insinuate someone has not read the article. This is against the rules. Please read the guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- blfr 9y agoBy appropriately I don't mean as a hack around this law or for grant money but according to the value delivered to the students. Then it would be fair for students to pay the tax just like it's presumably fair to pay undergrad tuition. Although it would probably have to be deferred somehow.
- jknoepfler 9y agoThe systematic erosion of public education in the United States doesn't serve anyone in the United States' long term interests, except maybe the religious right (who don't matter that much in the federal government). It just doesn't serve monied interests. It doesn't help big oil, it doesn't help big pharma, it doesn't help the legal or medical professions, it doesn't help finance, or insurance, or banking. So I'm a little puzzled. Who does it benefit? I share the author's bewilderment in the face of the realization that this is, in fact, terrible for universities, and (seemingly, given what we know) not just weird news spin-doctoring or scare mongering: "Given the existential risk to American higher education, why didn’t I blog about this earlier? ... It’s simply that I didn’t believe it—even given all the other stuff that could “never happen in the US,” until it happened this past year... Surely even the House Republicans would realize they’d screwed up this time, and would take out this crazy provision before the full bill was voted on? Or surely there’s some workaround that makes the whole thing less awful than it sounds? There has to be … right?" I'm also confused. I decided that I didn't have the right kind of information to understand what was happening in the Federal government a long time ago, and I still think that, but I find this whole situation very puzzling, because it doesn't make much sense given how I think the world works (which is, of course, a deeply flawed and nearly useless model of the real world).
- vvanders 9y agoI think if you view this through the lens of identity politics it makes a bit more sense why you're seeing such an attack on education and universities. When climate denial and the rejection of basic science is one of the pillars of the party then this is a logical extension.
- x0x0 9y agoThis is the point of the tax bill: to punish blue states and the educated. The removal of state income tax deductions; the cutting of mortgage interest deductions; and the removal of the graduate school tax break all point the same direction. As for Scott's suggestion that maybe universities can not charge, I can't possibly see that flying with the IRS. If the students still get that valuable education, taking something that used to cost $30k or more, declaring it "free" while still delivering the thing, and telling the irs that therefore, tada! no taxes are due! is... very unlikely to work. What we have is the removal of a specific tax break aimed at graduate school education in order to punish the educated.
- matt1234567 9y agoThe version of this bill which passed the Senate last night did not end the tuition tax credit [0]. Additionally, tax cuts do sometimes expire after a few years. For example, this info from Intuit indicates that the tuition tax credit in question expired at the end of 2016 [1]. Editing this upon a close rereading of [1]. I'm not sure if that refers to the same tuition tax credit. Any armchair tax lawyers care to weigh in? But, I have called my representatives and asked them to make sure that the credit survives reconciliation of the bill between the House and Senate, because I don't think that graduate student pay should be used as a bargaining chip. [0]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/11/30/what-is-in-the-senates-massive-tax-bill-and-what-could-change/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/11/30/what-... [1]: https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/college-and-education/deduction-for-higher-education/L0krerdUK https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/college-and-education/d...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CalChris 9y agoThe House version of the bill eliminates the student loan deduction for graduate students. This will be resolved in conference so it is still very much on the table.
- matt1234567 9y agoYes. My intent was to foster not complacency but hope - everyone reading this, please get on the phone with your representatives as soon as their offices open and tell them to keep the tuition credits while the bill is in conference! https://whoismyrepresentative.com https://whoismyrepresentative.com
- vintageseltzer 9y agoAn uneducated society is easy to manipulate — easy to convince that climate change isn't real, that evolution is a conspiracy against religion, that creating a social safety net and investing in public education, health care and modern infrastructure is a bad thing. I hate to turn social issues into black and white, partisan debates. But anti-intellectualism and the denigration of education is a uniquely right-wing phenomenon in the U.S. It's used often by the Republican party here to criticize "elites" and is employed by a long list of other power-hungry demagogues throughout world history [1]. Isaac Asimov wrote a column in January 1980 in Newsweek that describes this phenomenon in the U.S.: > There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there always has been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge." I encourage everyone to read the full column [2]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-intellectualism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-intellectualism [2]: https://aphelis.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ASIMOV_1980_Cult_of_Ignorance.pdf https://aphelis.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/ASIMOV_1980_C...
- corporateguy5 9y agoYou are confusing the idea of academia with the reality of it...
- dclowd9901 9y ago> An uneducated society is easy to manipulate This is nonsense. There’s no Illuminati out to make the population dumber. There _is_ a bunch of identity politics ignoramouses out the gut colleges that “corrupt our values” and it’s an easy thing to point to as a win when your base (who keep you in power) are mouth breathing retards who see higher education (and intelligence in general) as nuisances. Make no mistake: their goal is more money for companies, and this is merely a way to keep their base happy so they can keep their shareholders happy.
- philwelch 9y agoOpposing the state of American universities isn’t necessarily anti-intellectualism any more than opposing the state of the Roman Catholic Church is necessarily atheism.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- theptip 9y agoI found this article to be quite hysterical (and I follow and enjoy Aaronson's blog). It fails to present (or even consider) that there is a reasonable justification for these tax code changes, and instead leaps to "Trump and the Republicans must be evil and are out to crush all liberal edifices". An article recently posted here on HN gives a more nuanced explanation for what's going on: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15807842 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15807842 TL;DR, the tuition fee deferral scheme that universities currently use is a grant-money laundering scheme. It's used to take federal grant money that comes with strings attached (e.g. can only be spent on certain things like paying salaries for grad students, or research costs) and launder it into money that can be spent on whatever the university wants (e.g. building new campuses or paying for nice desks for administrators). It's probably not unreasonable for the federal government to try to close this loophole. The issue is that students are caught in the crossfire here, and I'm not sure that the incentives are there for universities to protect them fully. But to be clear, the universities could just stop billing the government false grad student salaries, and then grad students' take home pay and tax exposure would remain unchanged, and there would be no crisis. The problem is that then universities would have to find a new money laundering scheme, or would have to make structural changes to their budgets that they would prefer not to make.
- dmix 9y agoIt's sad that there seems to be little internal critique coming from within universities of the complete takeover of schools by administrators. When it does happen it's almost entirely the result of some external rumblings or a direct affront like this being twisted. I guess it's because these same administrators ultimately control the narratives (and budgets, jobs, etc) coming from the schools, creating a self-protecting cycle which only generates more administrative power. So when attempts to curtail their power happen they can twist it to make it seem like it's an attack on teachers, students, and research - instead of the separate group of people who consume the greatest amount of resources within the school, who don't generate the positive research and economic utility for which universities are typically known. Which is a shame, because there are probably no better people to stand up for this than the professors and researchers. Plenty of research has shown these people and their work aren't responsible for the massive increase in tuition and costs associated with schools. Yet the problem is perpetually the amount of revenue and income the school can make, not how it's being used.
- gravypod 9y ago> As you’ve probably heard, one of the ways Republicans intend to pay for their tax > giveaway, is to change the tax code so that graduate students will now need to > pay taxes on “tuition”—a large sum of money (as much as $50,000/year) that > PhD students never actually see, that can easily exceed the stipends they do > see, and that’s basically just an accounting trick that serves the internal needs > of universities and granting agencies. If I'm working for a company, the company decides "it is required for you to have X. We will provide it to you as part of your compensation." That X is part of my compensation for working there. I don't see why it shouldn't be taxed. "It will cost me more money" is not an excuse to not be taxed. "The students never get the money" is invalid because colleges have deemed their "X" to be worth 50k. Let me phrase this situation a different way. Assume I start working for Bloomberg's HF trading group. They want me to live closer to my office and buy my a penthouse apartment half a block down. They pay for it (made the contract, own the building, pay the staff, etc) but it's in my name. It's my apartment. Is that part of my income? Shouldn't I be taxed for this apartment? I never actually see the money! I never actually get to spend the money! It's just something that has to happen for me to be on Bloomberg's HF trading team! I think that should be taxable. What do you think?
- zzleeper 9y agoIt's not really like the apartment example. When I was in grad school the tuition number was kind of an imaginary number. It was 60k or something like that, no idea. I never signed anything with that, was never billed for that, nothing. The only way I could know what that number was somewhere on my online account, where I saw: >> Charge: +$60,000 from Graduate School Division >> Payment: -$60,000 from Graduate Department of XYZ And that was not the value of the education either. Even in quarters where you are not physically in the school, with no classes, library access, etc. you would still be "charged" that magic number. It's just a way to allocate expenses between each department and the graduate school. In most cases they will just change the accounting to something even weirder, and the government will get nothing. Some schools, with arcane rules from donors (such as that their money can only be used for education and not infrastructure) will have problems. But for the most part it's just a stupid thing to do from the govt side, that will just complicate things even more.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tony_cannistra 9y agocached: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:YefHUeCtjZ0J:https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/%3Fp%3D3542+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:YefHUe...
- tdaltonc 9y agoI think that the grad student tax would increase the number of grad students. If the tax increase goes through, universities will probably respond my significantly increasing "indirects" and decreasing tuition. They could twiddle the numbers so that the university still makes the same average off of every grant, and students take homes don't change at all. But there would be in important difference: from a PI's perspective, grad students would be relatively cheaper. Paradoxically, taxing tuition may have the net effect of creating more grad student positions (while decreasing the spend on capital investments).
- starchild_3001 9y agoRepublicans are anti-science, anti-immigration to the extent they want to curb university research and stop the flow of world's smartest immigrants to USA. That's the only rational explanation of what's going on. If that wasn't the intent, the people who created and voted for this bill are the biggest idiots.