3 ms·
Well, it is a highly political topic. And I found no article yet, with technical details, about what they technically actual accomplished. The Reuters article
by hutzlibu 9y ago
Well, it is a highly political topic.
And I found no article yet, with technical details, about what they technically actual accomplished. The Reuters article is especially lacking any information, except stating that they succeded technically, but faced problems at the US border before and the latter they repeated many times, not just one quote.
So it looks a bit missleading and I would not call it journalism, if there is a agenda with it. And this seems to be the case here - directed against Trump and his Afghan ban etc.policy.
I mean sure, personally I despise that as well and I am highly against restricting people from going somewhere else, just because of their origin. And the girls are definitely courageous(their captains dad was killed by a suicide bombing this year) and maybe even did an outstanding job given their bad starting conditions ...
but I saw nothing convincing so far, like the article implys, that they build even remotely something like this:
"The team’s winning entry was a solar-powered robot that would help small farmers carry out tasks including seeding and cutting crops like wheat "
I read something about designing flyers, etc. for this product, which sounds more plausible - as designing an actual robot, even only with lego, who does remotely, what the quote says, is huge work and not doable with access to good education.
Which they don't have. So yes, I think they deserve praise for doing something while coming from where they are, but if news imply to me they did more, than they did(and possibly could do), for political reasons, even with good intentions, you could call it propaganda. And I think this is not helping.
As then also people like me, who have lot's of sympathy for disadvantaged people at tech - and beeing a girl from Afghanistan is probably as disadvantaged as you can get, get the impression, that they mainly won their price because of being who they are and not what they did.
And this is a shame, because maybe they are even technically very gifted and did outstanding. But now I mistrust the whole thing ... and possibly also the next thing I hear from high tech girls from Afghanistan ...
(edits: updadet a bit)
- onetimeusename 9y agoOne of the reasons, I assume, it is difficult to gain access to the US, even for teams of student-scientists, is because of things like this happening https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2017/07/23/mystery-deepens-after-african-teens-vanish-u-s-robotics-fair/502903001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2017/07/23/mystery....
- pavlov 9y agoWell, it is a highly political topic. Have you asked yourself why? Fundamentally this is about a group of children traveling to participate in an entrepreneurial competition. There is nothing inherently political about that. Who made it political? Who benefits from creating divisions that have made these children’s entry in a competition such a loaded question?
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Who made it political? Who benefits from creating divisions that have made these children’s entry in a competition such a loaded question?" I think basically 2 things come into play: One is good intentioned propaganda, to support underprivileged poor girls, by exaggerating what they can do - to try to persuade immigration-unfriendly people into more openness, like hey they are good for our economy, if we only let them in. Secondly, but connected: opposition to Trump and co. and the whole power struggle in the US. So in this context, I would see the message as, poor, lovely and technology outstanding girls beeing denied entry to the US for a competition, because of evil Trump and his politics. (which is why he did intervene personally to show that he is not so bad, and only wants to keep the bad people out blabla) But I doubt, that any side really cared for the girls as humans. ... so high politics as usual, I think.
- pavlov 9y agoSo you don't think the original decision by US authorities to deny entry to these children was political? Because your answer only blames the other side for politicizing the issue under labels of "propaganda" and "power struggle". That speaks of a mindset where any decision made by law enforcement authorities is apolitical, and any questioning of said decisions is political. It's the same mindset where American police are always just doing their job the best they can, while Black Lives Matters is a dangerous anarchist movement. Oddly this mindset only extends to the sectors of government that are authorized to use power. Anybody else working in the public sector is part of "the swamp".
- hutzlibu 9y ago