3 ms·
Your rephrasing actually changes the question. It says that the scenario is run repeatedly, while the question is about a one-off event. By phrasing it as one o
by mannykannot 9y ago
Your rephrasing actually changes the question. It says that the scenario is run repeatedly, while the question is about a one-off event. By phrasing it as one of a series of events, you have told the subject how to go about answering the problem.
In an earlier reply, I suggested that the only way to interpret the question as posed is that the host is not making a random selection, and the question would have to be phrased differently to allow an interpretation in which the host's choice is random - e.g."the host flips a coin to pick one of the closed boxes which, when opened, reveals a goat".