3 ms·
> The original wording with the nonchalant "say" in the middle of ", opens another door, _say_ No. 3, which has a goat" makes it seems like there was no link be
by mcphage 9y ago
> The original wording with the nonchalant "say" in the middle of ", opens another door, _say_ No. 3, which has a goat" makes it seems like there was no link between the host's knowledge of what's behind the door and the opening of door #3 and therefore random. Therefore, the 50/50 probability seemed to be the correct answer.
If the host opened a door at random, then sometimes that door would contain the car. At which point, the entire exercise is meaningless—the host would in effect be asking "do you want to switch your door (which you know contains a goat) for another door (which you know contains a goat)?"
Asking the question at all when they just lost—especially given that the host just cost them the game is clearly not a desirable scenario for any game show.
So any interpretation of the problem which would allow for this scenario can be easily discarded as incorrect.