3 ms·
To be clear, as we are all in agreement that the correct answer is the same whether the question states the host has knowledge or not, there is no doubt here th
by mannykannot 9y ago
To be clear, as we are all in agreement that the correct answer is the same whether the question states the host has knowledge or not, there is no doubt here that the question, exactly as stated, is unambiguous and has one correct answer. If someone chooses to use faulty reasoning in solving it, they have made a mistake as surely as if they had made an arithmetical error in calculating the odds incorrectly. Mathematicians and philosophers, in particular, are supposed to know how to be rigorous.
I think this has wandered across the threshold into "if they were asked a different question, they would have given a different answer", which might be true, and, if tested experimentally, might throw some light on why this problem seems unreasonably baffling, though it would be hard to find sufficient suitable candidates for this experiment (maybe among schoolchildren who have shown they have a good grasp of the relevant statistics).
Personally, I would guess that people are led down the wrong path by causal intuition - i.e. "opening the second box makes no difference to where the prize is", or perhaps by an intuition that the choice to switch or not is as random a choice (i.e. over uniform odds) as their initial pick. I realize that at this point, these guesses have no more evidence for them than does the hypothesis that people are being misled by language clues.