7 ms·
Some people want to live in a place that looks like this: http://www.unitedcountry.com/CountryHomes/img/Country_Homes_7.jpg http://www.unitedcountry.com/Countr
by lisper 9y ago
Some people want to live in a place that looks like this:
http://www.unitedcountry.com/CountryHomes/img/Country_Homes_7.jpg http://www.unitedcountry.com/CountryHomes/img/Country_Homes_...
and some people want to live in a place that looks like this:
https://www.cmgsite.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Presidio-Landmark-0031.jpg https://www.cmgsite.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Presidio-...
and some people want to live in a place that looks like this:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/Hong_Kong_Skyline_Restitch_-_Dec_2007.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/23/Hong_Kon...
The problem is that someone who moves to the first type of place doesn't want to have to move again when it turns into the second type of place, and someone who moves to the second type of place doesn't want to move again when it turns into the third type of place. It's not entirely unreasonable.
- Groxx 9y agoNot entirely unreasonable, definitely. But it seems somewhat expect-able over the course of a lifetime. A lifetime ago the world was a rather different place, and I imagine the same was true of the lifetime before that. Seems like you either stay and fight (which history implies does not work) or keep moving to new similar-to-before places. Always. Expecting otherwise is not entirely reasonable either.
- philwelch 9y agoWell I guess we just need to figure out how to geographically distribute the world's human population once and for all and never do anything that will ever require that to change, then.
- lliamander 9y agoOr you could let the people who live in a given place have a vote as to whether they are OK with new housing. And if the local residents don't want a new housing development because it negatively impacts their home value, then maybe someone will find a way to make it worth their while (i.e. real-estate developer grants current residents a stake in the returns of the new development if they stay for 5 years after the new housing is constructed).
- philwelch 9y ago> Or you could let the people who live in a given place have a vote as to whether they are OK with new housing. This is the local equivalent of Trump-style “close the borders and build a wall” anti-immigration rhetoric.
- dionidium 9y agoIt's not entirely unreasonable. You're right. It's not at all -- like not even a little bit -- unreasonable to desire that your neighborhood stay the way it was on the day you bought into it. That's why you bought there in the first place, presumably; you liked it the way it was! But it is 100% unreasonable to expect the rest of the world to help you achieve that goal. Times change. Places change. Building more density in the Bay Area is good for the most people and should be supported on those grounds. I desire a lot of things. They aren't unreasonable desires. But that doesn't make them good policy goals for society as a whole.
- closeparen 9y agoI don't think it's controversial that NIMBYism is bad for society. It is controversial that society, rather than local or hyper-local (block-level) residents, should write zoning policy.
- BrainInAJar 9y agoThere should not be zoning policy. It exists out of racist midcentury policy to keep "those sorts of people" out of the neighborhood
- gehwartzen 9y agoOr to keep an oil refinery out of the neighborhood.
- closeparen 9y agoThere are plenty of industrial uses that it's perfectly sane to segregate from residential neighborhoods. I might agree that zoning should be all-or-nothing with respect to residential uses, and that there should not be such a thing as a "luxury residential only" (i.e. single family home only) zone.
- dionidium 9y agoInterestingly, this is what NIMBY used to mean (i.e. we all agree there should be industry/prisons/landfills/etc, just please not near me). But this is something totally different. This is just urban incumbents opposing further urban developments in their neighborhoods on the grounds that they’ve got theirs and there’s no upside to making it any easier for other people to move there, too. This isn’t about keeping the oil refinery out. This is about keeping other people out. That’s a fundamentally different thing. NIMBY isn’t even the right word for it.
- bradleyjg 9y agoI rent my apartment. I know that I might have to move. The people that own the building might want to do something else with it and since they own it that's their choice. Single family homeowners own their own homes. It can't get sold out from underneath them. But they don't own the plots next store or across the street. If their happiness with their living situation is dependent on those plots having the same buildings on them then they need to buy those plots too. Then they get to decide what happens to them. A homeowner NIMBYite is exactly the same as a renter that agitates for imposing rent control.
- vvanders 9y agoSorta. When we lived in the city I had to file a permit to fix my 3' high fence. Pay something like $100 just to have "permission" to start working on something that was rotting and falling over. I don't really consider that "owning". Ditto zoning and a bunch of other things. When we had the chance we moved out to the country so we could use our land how we wanted without having to live in the covenants of what the city lays down(for instance one of the local towns doesn't allow beekeeping, regardless of plot size). I totally understand that there's a place for high density living and that some people enjoy that life. However when you see rapid change in these tech centers understand that are some people didn't sign up for that when it came around. [edit] I should add that I really wish more companies would support remote work. It both solves the housing issue and lets people live in the areas that fit their lifestyle better.
- BlytheSchuma 9y agoOn a side note: Can we talk about fence height restrictions? Ain't that some bullshit?
- lovich 9y agoeh, a shitty neighbor can make for an easy case on fence restrictions. Its one thing if you have a legitimate reason to put a high fence up, but removing all restrictions would make it really easy for a neighbor to fuck someone over. Say your neighbor is on your south side and puts up a fence that blocks a lot of sunlight to your land, now your garden is useless or you have to spend more money on lighting. Another example, though not for height, would be putting a fence up along your shared driveway up to the street, now theyve made it more dangerous for you to just get out of your house onto the road
- TulliusCicero 9y agoNot unreasonable to have that desire, just like it's not unreasonable for me to desire people throwing money at me in the streets. Just unreasonable for me to expect society to cave to my desires when it's in not in society's long-term interest to do so. Ever increasing property values caused by artificially restricted zoning is basically a generational Ponzi scheme. It's stupid and wrong and it can't last forever. And like real Ponzi schemes, the only people who benefit are those who got in early.
- lisper 9y agoIf you want to look at it that way, all of human civilization is a giant Ponzi scheme. Exponential growth cannot be sustained indefinitely on a finite planet, or even in a finite universe.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoNo, because human civilization doesn't depend on that growth. A stable population works fine. Whereas, the whole "enrich myself off property values" thing only works if those values are continually increasing.
- lisper 9y ago> A stable population works fine. That is far from clear. No human civilization has ever had a stable population. > the whole "enrich myself off property values" thing only works if those values are continually increasing. That's true, but that's not what I was talking about. What I was talking about is people's reasonable desire for a stable environment. Rising housing costs is just a side-effect of that plus population growth. You might as well blame the situation on people who have babies as on people who want to limit growth in their communities.