7 ms·
> But they also don't really have a good alternative that wouldn't lose them a lot of money in a time where, if they're not in the class that owns multiple hous
by ajross 9y ago
> But they also don't really have a good alternative that wouldn't lose them a lot of money in a time where, if they're not in the class that owns multiple houses, they're already struggling
These people are property owners in Berkeley, California. While I'm sure yarns can be spun about the difference between asset value and cash liquidity, this is just not an impoverished class, sorry. They've seen their property values go through the roof, then the trees, now through the first cloud layer into the open sky with eyes toward low orbit. Arguing that they don't have an "alternative" is a little spun.
To wit: cry me a river. Build those homes.
- bagels 9y agoNot everyone who owns a home has purchased it decades ago...
- ajross 9y agoPer Zillow, the very house in the linked article is up 14.6% just in the last 12 months. Decades what now?
- smsm42 9y agoIf somebody bought it recently, chances are they own no more that 20-30% of it. Which means if the value goes up 14%, they are in good place (though not seeing a cent of that money until they move), but if the value goes down 20%, they are in trouble. And if they have to move, they are in real trouble.
- incompatible 9y agoI had the impression (from the last financial crisis) that if prices go down, home owners just mail the keys to the bank and walk away. Assuming they have little equity to start with, of course.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoI get the feeling this was written about more often than it happened. A lot of journalists were trying to justify their salary with ad views while the economy was in free fall.
- Godel_unicode 9y agoDo you have data or any sources to go with this feeling?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lamarpye 9y agoIt would be nice if the article provided some data.
- pault 9y agoFine, but those people are not going to be getting another loan any time soon.
- ajross 9y agoThey are, actually. The market is hot again, and banks aren't idiots: they know that people pay their mortgages before other debt, even if they have a foreclosure in their past. Walking away from an underwater loan (which is a rational decision that connotes good decisions in the future) doesn't actually hurt your credit in the same way that getting behind on your credit cards does (which is evidence for poor money management skills).
- smsm42 9y agoIt's not that simple. Bankruptcy or foreclosure ruins your credit and you have still to live somewhere.
- bradleyjg 9y agoWait, highly levered investments are risky -- who knew?
- kareemm 9y agoThat's unfortunate, but I'm not sure where it's written that investments must always go up.
- einarvollset 9y agoNo, and nowhere is it written that you get to decide when existing rules should be changed.
- kareemm 9y agoOur democratically elected legislators make and change the rules. It's not clear to me why they should preserve the value of an asset for a few people just because the asset might go down. Especially if there's a high cost to people who don't own similar assets. Can you help me understand why that's a good idea?
- WillPostForFood 9y agoDemocratically elected legislators can also choose not to make new or change existing rules. If you want to leave it to democracy, that's why we have what we do now.
- leggomylibro 9y agoYeah, I feel you. But I also feel for people who have worked their whole lives to build towards a comfortable retirement, put their lives' worth of sweat and tears into that, and then had it pulled out from under them. There's a hyperbole to express on both sides, but I can understand why people who are worth $1-5 million and are past their 50s might feel threatened by this sort of development. They aren't in a particularly marginalized position, but they are probably frightened about the rapid change and possibly out hundreds of thousands of dollars plus time they don't have. I agree, build those homes and reduce the power of small groups to put up large barriers, but I also understand where the residents are coming from to some degree.
- morgante 9y ago> There's a hyperbole to express on both sides, but I can understand why people who are worth $1-5 million and are past their 50s might feel threatened by this sort of development. They can sell their house and live a life of luxury virtually anywhere else in the world. I have a hard time sympathizing with such people. They're not out anything—they're amongst the most privileged people in the country. Sure, I understand where they're coming from. That doesn't mean they have my sympathy. I understand why billionaires advocate for lowering their own taxes—that doesn't mean I give them an ounce of sympathy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- einarvollset 9y agoGive your mum a call (you’re clearly young, so she’s likely alive), tell her that she has to move to somewhere 5x cheaper. There are lots of places all over the world that would make sense. I understand why that might be uncomfortable for her - that doesn’t mean i should give her one ounce of sympathy. Amirite?
- morgante 9y agoMy mom has moved plenty of times in her life. It's not like moving is a crazy abnormality—tons of people move when they retire.
- Clubber 9y ago>To wit: cry me a river. Build those homes. Why not just build a massive cluster of skyscrapers and put all the people who want cheap rent there? It would cause much less impact on the existing homeowners at large. To me that is a much more equitable solution for both parties. Personally, I would say if you can't afford to live there, don't. There are plenty of places to live and many people do.
- BrainInAJar 9y ago> Why not just build a massive cluster of skyscrapers and put all the people who want cheap rent there? 1: where? and 2: these homeowners will oppose it, because it still drives down the value of their investment because it drives down demand. There is no way to drive down demand but keep prices high. That's not how economics works.
- Clubber 9y ago1. Pick a few contiguous blocks, it doesn't really matter where. 2. The logic being, if you have to screw people out of their equity (retirement) might as well make the smallest footprint.
- guywaffle 9y agoScrewing people out of retirement? When you buy a house there is no contract with the city to keep the city from expending and improving. Such an agreement would be against capitalism. And... What about the teachers, janitors, and other necessary individuals that make a community work? Most of them have to drive hours just to get to work in the Bay Area since all the housing is going to engineers making at least 100k a year.
- bitshepherd 9y agoFor a single earner making at least $100k a year, I'm looking at moving away from the Bay Area for any notion of not blowing $50k on rent every year. I can't even touch the housing market in an area inconvenient to my work without literally hundreds of thousands of dollars in liquidity. That is cash that I simply do not have, nor do I have wealthy relatives that can front me the money. Please don't assume that just because an engineer has, what looks like a high income on paper, that they can even afford houses that cost millions of dollars in a high cost of living region as the Bay Area. My coworkers that have set down roots here have to drive hours, and they're also making "at least 100k a year". What about the engineers that need jobs and homes, and the people that move just for their job? City's full, go away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JSDave 9y agoSomebody's investment doing well isn't a reason to penalize them. Lots of things have had way higher returns than single family homes.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoHaha yes! Perspective.
- tomrod 9y agoConsider your logic in a different manner: I assume you work in some form of technology. Technology and related jobs have seen their wages increase astronomically compared to textiles or fast food. Sorry, you're not impoverished. You, and everyone else in your town, are now subject to 100% tax above a certain threshold, at 110% of full time minimum wage. This is so we can give that money to people who chose to not enter technology. Ridiculous. Moderate taxation on a progressive marginal increase is fine. The extreme is absurd. Property rights are what make trade work without having to hire armed thugs. I absolutely reject the notion that a home owner's personal reserve price to walk away from their property should be coercable. That being said, my neighbor should have little say over what happens on my property outside of mutually agreed covenants.
- archagon 9y agoIf your argument is “these people should feel differently”, then you have already lost. Their votes and community involvement are, in the end, the only things that matter. Your principles mean nothing; they need to be convinced.
- ryguytilidie 9y agoThis is the biggest failing of modern debate. It seems like we've thrown compassion and putting ourselves in other people's shoes and now just say "your view is stupid, change it". Imagine someone presenting that to you? Is your immediate thought "hm, you're right! convincing point!" or "Go fuck yourself"?
- nasredin 9y agoIt seems that reluctance to consider other views is closely related to the level of education, and place of upbringing. This IS not a failing in modern debate, but a much bigger issue. I have seen less educated people show zero empathy for the opposing side many more times than the reverse. Also you cannot have debates with some people, e.g. right wing authoritarians. Some people are just born that way.
- mantas 9y agoEducated left wingers seem to be most ignorant tbh.
- ericd 9y agoRight, it's not about education as much as it is knowing people who don't share the same views as you. If everyone you know thinks the same way you do (which is as common among left wingers as right), then it's much easier to believe that people who don't share your views must be insane/less than human/your enemy.
- fiter 9y agoFrom the article, it turns out that their opinions eventually did not matter. It would be nice to change their opinion at least so they aren't bitter about it.
- ams6110 9y agoAlso considering it's Berkeley, I'd wager many of those same people sanctimoniously decried urban sprawl, favored high density, walkable, sustainable development... but when it was going to happen next door they were as NIMBY as anyone else.