3 ms·
> Corporations are people after all, aren't they? This was an effort to protect the economy from being ground to a halt by destructive litigious action and mak
by dmix 9y ago
> Corporations are people after all, aren't they?
This was an effort to protect the economy from being ground to a halt by destructive litigious action and make courts more efficient. Not to increase liability and accountability within the corporation. Which is why nearly every western country has done the same... it wasn't a conspiracy to protect wealthy people from being punished.
Like many regulations that fail to affect idealistic change, it was done with good intentions and there hasn't been a strong enough support for an alternative to solve this issue... or, less likely, maybe no rational alternatives really do exist.
The simple fact is shit rolls down hill in all big organizations and I'm not convinced it won't happen if corporations weren't singular legal entities. Top tier executives have a way of protecting themselves, while the lower staff tend not to have such protections.
Removing this 'corporations = people' legal structure would incentivize internal deflection to lower levels as a legal strategy instead of the company uniformly fighting back against allegations - making it risky to be a low-level manager and highly disincentivizing employees from taking any real responsibility that would involve legal exposure (aka a huge percentage of management and entrepreneurial jobs).
Ultimately, the tough reality is that it might actually make sense to treat the company as a singular whole, as potentially there are hundreds of people involved in any major corporate incident. Which would be a nightmare in the bureaucratic mess that is the modern justice system.
That said, I'm not 100% convinced that courts can't use common sense to figure out direct liability and involvement within the company, at an individual level. But common sense has never been something the courts or government policy have been known for, at least in the last half-century. The modern justice system has entirely been modeled around the lowest common denominator. Which is very apparent if you've ever tried to challenge something as simple as a traffic ticket in court.
Given that legal/regulatory environment which it currently exists within I could see such a change being abused and being massively inefficient. Especially considering how difficult it is to prove a single persons involvement in a normal crime, let alone trying to sue a company then figuring out 100 individuals culpability...
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>it wasn't some conspiracy to protect wealthy people from ever getting punished. That has been the result, however.
- dmix 9y agoRegardless, my point is that it's entirely possible that without this current legal structure the alternatives will only increase low-level employees legal exposure, while having a marginal impact on the behaviour of wealthy top level executives (which is what people really care about, isn't it?), and while simultaneously flooding the courts with massive inefficient cases, consuming finite resources which could be better spent elsewhere. Just because you can point out the current system's flaws doesn't automatically mean a comparable better one exists. Plenty of systems in our economy and legal system are a matter of lesser-of-evils. It's easy to complain but unless you can propose a better alternative, an alternative that won't end up being worse for the poor/middle class average person, then you aren't really helping the situation. This disconnect from the on-the-ground reality is one of the big reasons I don't support many of these populist activist causes... and yes I've seen "The Corporation" film many times.
- enraged_camel 9y ago>>Just because you can point out the current system's flaws doesn't automatically mean a comparable better one exists. The flip side of the coin is we should never stop looking for improvements. IMO if executives were held personally liable for gross negligence, for instance, they would suddenly become more interested in things like security best practices (referring to the recent Equifax disaster).
- focusgroup0 9y agoThanks for this, feel like there is too much FUD out there on Citizens United.
- forapurpose 9y ago> it was done with good intentions How can anyone know the motivations of the Justices? > Like many regulations Isn't it a court decision, not a regulation? Are we all talking about Citizens United? > This was an effort to protect the economy from being ground to a halt by destructive litigious action and make courts more efficient. Is there evidence that such a thing was at risk of happening? I know industry advocates commonly make the claim, but I haven't seen evidence. IIRC, the court decision was to enable corporations to make political contributions based on their free speech rights as 'people'. How does that serve the purposes quoted above?
- slavik81 9y ago> Isn't it a court decision, not a regulation? Are we all talking about Citizens United? No. He's probably talking about the establishment of corporations by the Joint Stock Companies Act of 1844[1], or its American equivalent. Citizens United did not invent corporate personhood. That dates back to when the concept of a corporation was first established. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Stock_Companies_Act_1844 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_Stock_Companies_Act_1844
- evgen 9y agoAnd the prior comment references Santa Clara vs Southern Pacific Railway, in which a note on the decisions (not even in the decision itself) stated that corporations were persons for purposes of the 14th amendment. It does not date back to the Joint Stock Companies act but comes from a little later in the post-civil war cases.
- 1_2__4 9y agoI like how you carefully catalog the theoretical damage a recent court precedent going the other way would have inflicted, and just as carefully ignore the actual fallout we’ve already seen from it.