4 ms·
>Learning statistics is a tautology. Meaning: the best way to learn statistics is to already know statistics. Go google how to do basic significance calculation
by BeetleB 9y ago
>Learning statistics is a tautology. Meaning: the best way to learn statistics is to already know statistics. Go google how to do basic significance calculations in, say, Excel. The first paragraph of the resulting articles will dive into t-test and twin-tales and P-values and on down the lines.
I'm not sure what you mean by this. Or rather, your statement is true for all disciplines.
Your question: How do I do a significance calculation?
This automatically should mean you have basic statistical knowledge. How else would you know what a significance test is? In my introductory statistics course, we were taught p-values and t-tests. Why is it so problematic that people who want to use a statistical test should know what is considered introductory material?
>Software needs to bridge the gap between users' intent and their ability to do the analysis. Statistics requires R (you have to know how to program and statistics), SAS ($$$), or another package that limits barrier to entry. Most people know how to ask the basic question, but no idea how to get the answer or interpret the results.
Again: Is that not true for many disciplines? It is always easy to ask basic questions: When I type in a URL in my browser, how does my browser get the information it is showing me? The answer is not something the layperson will understand.
The issue with statistics is that answering simple questions can be complex. What is considered significant actually depends on the problem domain. You need to know what level of significance is good enough for the problem. And if you do not know how the significance test actually calculates things, you will not know if the level of significance you specify is accurate for your problem. It would be scary if my statistics tool gave me simple binary answers ("Yes, these two variables are related") - that would often be wrong and prone to misuse.
I think the problem with statistics is that we don't do enough of it. My undergrad had one class in it, and we never used it outside that class. Yet when I look at skills needed in the real world, statistics is high on the list - higher than many engineering courses I took, and definitely higher than most mathematics courses I took. Most engineers never use calculus outside of school - yet they can still do basic differentiation and integration. But most of them cannot do basic statistics - and many of them have a need to do statistics on the job.
I think typical engineering courses should try hard to put in statistical elements to their homework assignments.