4 ms·
He's not alone in applying physics math to number theory. One thing that makes mathematicians leery of physics-inspired proofs is that physicists accept mathem
by ncmncm 9y ago
He's not alone in applying physics math to number theory. One thing that makes mathematicians leery of physics-inspired proofs is that physicists accept mathematical transformations that produce correct experimental results but that have not been proven axiomatically.
For example, here is a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis:
http://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.5012170 http://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.5012170
It uses operations on an analytic continuation of the zeta function. Are they OK? I don't know. If they are, it's Fields Medal material.
But this is nothing new. Oliver Heaviside revolutionized differential equation solving with the Heaviside Operator, which gives correct answers to electromagnetic problems. Nowadays we call it the Laplace Transform, because Laplace had used what turned out equivalent, for other purposes.
- qubex 9y agoNever heard of Oliver Heaveside and his operator despite using Laplace transforms on a regular basis for year. You learn something new every day. Thanks.
- Cyph0n 9y agoMy diff equations textbook referred to it as the Heaviside operator. In my EE and control classes, it's called the Laplace transform.
- ncmncm 9y agoOther reasons Heaviside is often ignored are that he was a commoner, and he published all his papers in a newspaper. He originated the theory of transmission lines (inventing the loading coils you still see hanging between telephone poles) and atmospheric radio propagation, both often credited to others. See Paul Nahin, "Oliver Heaviside: Sage in Solitude"
- Cyph0n 9y agoNow that's very interesting! According to his wiki page, he reduced Maxwell's equations from 20 equations (in 20 variables) down to the 4 iconic equations we now refer to as Maxwell's equations. Imagine having to learn EM theory with 20 equations... as if current EM theory courses aren't tough enough already! One of his creations, the step function, is also a key part of many proofs and equations in signal processing.
- ncmncm 9y agoIt should be noted that Maxwell's quaternion formulation of the same relations has just two equations. Vector notation won out over quaternions not from elegance or power, but from practical details of working them on paper. Now that we don't, anymore, quaternions are probably the better notation. Somebody should rewrite an E-M and an optics textbook.
- catnaroek 9y agopls, we use tensor calculus and exterior algebra. More, precisely, the electromagnetic tensor is the exterior derivative of the 4-potential.
- kurthr 9y agoExactly, vector calculus is a useful learning tool, but not used in most higher level (e.g. General Rel, plasma physics, etc) or numerical (super computer) physics calculations. Raising and lowering Kartoffel symbols and their covariant derivative forms make manipulating the coordinate transforms possible (4-6 dimensional)... otherwise it would just look like pages of equations. Interestingly, mechanical engineering also deals almost entirely with tensors... and they've developed extremely intuitive visualization tools.
- mkl 9y ago> Interestingly, mechanical engineering also deals almost entirely with tensors... and they've developed extremely intuitive visualization tools. What visualisation tools are you referring to? That sounds interesting.
- kurthr 9y agoSince all 3D stress/strains are tensor quantities (even for purely linear models), MEs project them into principal axes so that you can see their angle and their peak tesnsile/shear stress. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cauchy_stress_tensor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cauchy_stress_tensor Look at Mohr's circle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohr%27s_circle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohr%27s_circle Within an object the stresses and strains (and principal components) vary as you move through it. That's part of what makes predicting failures and effects of thermal expansion so complex, etc difficult even ignoring nonlinear effects and failure modes (e.g. crack propagation).
- empath75 9y agoWhat kind of newspaper publishes scientific papers?
- ncmncm 9y agoI guess Nahin called it a newspaper because it came out on newsprint, folded over, weekly. It would be called a trade rag, these days, if we had those anymore. https://books.google.com/books?id=ehJbAAAAYAAJ&dq=intitle%3AThe%20electrician&pg=PA10-IA3#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=ehJbAAAAYAAJ&dq=intitle%3A...
- emmelaich 9y agoHe's responsible for the form of Maxwell's equations that we use today.
- 21 9y ago> One thing that makes mathematicians leery of physics-inspired proofs is that physicists accept mathematical transformations that produce correct experimental results but that have not been proven axiomatically. I think it's way beyond that. Physicists are know to be fast and loose with their maths. For a period of time they were basically deleting infinities which appeared in the equations and pretended everything was fine, because after this operation the results agreed with experiments. To quote Dirac: I must say that I am very dissatisfied with the situation, because this so-called "good theory" does involve neglecting infinities which appear in its equations, neglecting them in an arbitrary way. This is just not sensible mathematics. Sensible mathematics involves neglecting a quantity when it turns out to be small—not neglecting it just because it is infinitely great and you do not want it! Only later mathematicians put this technique on more proper grounds - renormalization.
- ncmncm 9y agoIn other words, physicists were entirely correct to toss the infinite values, and mathematicians were later persuaded it was mathematically sound. Nowadays, although physicists say they are "renormalizing", they still just toss the infinite values. They're justified by results of experiments. Mathematicians are limited because, typically, they have no handy universe to run experiments in, never mind budget for a supercollider.
- wolfgke 9y ago> In other words, physicists were entirely correct to toss the infinite values, and mathematicians were later persuaded it was mathematically sound. Rather: Mathematicians were able to develop an axiomatic framework in which these transformations have a well-defined meaning.
- ncmncm 9y agoPotato, potahto. If the experiment produced different results, mathematicians would not be asked for an opinion until the physicists came up with some other math. Because the experiment matched, mathematicians were obliged to invent a framework to justify it.
- naasking 9y ago> One thing that makes mathematicians leery of physics-inspired proofs is that physicists accept mathematical transformations that produce correct experimental results but that have not been proven axiomatically. That's interesting. Any good examples where this turned out badly, in the sense that the formalism turned out to be inconsistent or something?
- ncmncm 9y agoString theory has no experiments, so has no touchstone to justify dodgy maths. String theorists routinely depend on the infinite sum 1 + 2 + 3 + ... = -1/12, without apology. It's anybody's guess how well that will turn out in the end, but it hasn't interfered with grants, publication, or tenure, so it's OK so far.
- felipemnoa 9y ago>>infinite sum 1 + 2 + 3 + ... = -1/12 Sounds interesting. What is the name of this?
- Theyeaheach 9y agohttps://youtu.be/w-I6XTVZXww https://youtu.be/w-I6XTVZXww
- ctchocula 9y agoI learned about it through this Numberphile video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-I6XTVZXww https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-I6XTVZXww There's also a nice write-up from Terry Tao: https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclaurin-formula-bernoulli-numbers-the-zeta-function-and-real-variable-analytic-continuation/ https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/04/10/the-euler-maclauri...
- qmalzp 9y agoTl;Dr It's slightly more accurate to say if F(s) = 1^s + 2^s + 3^s + ... Then F(1) = -1/12. This is still a lie, but the truth is that F(s) does make sense for a large domain of s, and there is a unique and canonical way of extending F(s) to a larger domain which contains 1. And then that new function evaluated at 1 is equal to -1/12.
- emmelaich 9y agoHas anyone else had the thought that physics is actually more fundamental that mathematics? Also, read this article made me think of Feynman's advice which was something like 'look for symmetries and look for conservation'
- gowld 9y agoTheoretical physics "shut up and calculate" is experimental mathematics.
- andrewflnr 9y agoYes, but not in a way that's germane here. Physics in the sense of the workings of the world is fundamental. Physics in the sense of science practiced by humans is infamous for spherical cows, point masses and mathematical funny business. Not the same thing at all. :)
- qubex 9y agoThe “look for symmetries and conservation” edict is a direct emanation of Emily Noether's (First) Theorem, which basically places conserved quantities of a system of differential equations with the symmetry groups that system must exhibit. A deep, amazing, beautiful, bi-directional relationship between differential dynamics and abstract group algebra.
- andrepd 9y agoThat's a discussion that doesn't make much sense. What do you mean by "more fundamental"? The fact is physics and mathematics treat entirely different subjects. Physics treats the physical, empirical world. Mathematics is the study of formal thought. It isn't meaningful to compare them that way.
- tim333 9y agoOr perhaps at the root they are the same thing.