4 ms·
This isn't a particularly good example, because on a blockchain, both the currency received and the equity percentage of ownership of the company are numbers th
by nostrademons 9y ago
This isn't a particularly good example, because on a blockchain, both the currency received and the equity percentage of ownership of the company are numbers that go onto the blockchain and can be cryptographically enforced. A blockchain simply wouldn't let you write a contract that says "I give $X in exchange for Y% equity in this entity" unless it could prove that you have ownership of $X.
The real advantages of a human judicial system come when there's a judgment call involved in the contract. For example, "I own X% of 500 startups and have control over future investment decisions, unless it can be shown that I have violated the laws of the United States, some of which happen to be about sexual harassment." What constitutes sexual harassment? Damned if a blockchain knows. It's hard enough for humans to come to agreement on that, let alone computers.
- matthewowen 9y agoBut what if the contract is "I will give you $X in three months time in exchange for Y% equity in this entity"? It's not unusual to enter a contract that obliges you to pay money you do not yet have at some future date when you do expect to have it. If your contract system doesn't allow that then it isn't a very useful contract system.
- modeless 9y ago> A blockchain simply wouldn't let you write a contract that says "I give $X in exchange for Y% equity in this entity" unless it could prove that you have ownership of $X. A blockchain absolutely would let you write a contract that does that, and it could be on purpose or by accident. If you want to be sure your contract doesn't accidentally or maliciously do that, you have to audit it ahead of time because once it's executed, you're screwed. There's no judge who can come in after the fact and nullify some of your contract provisions based on fraud or mistakes or conflict with existing laws or other totally reasonable considerations that aren't explicitly coded into the contract ahead of time.