4 ms·
Do you want a building to be beautiful or functional? Seems like a false dichotomy to me. I mean, you can choose which elements of old buildings to copy and w
by michaelt 9y ago
Do you want a building to be beautiful or functional?
Seems like a false dichotomy to me.
I mean, you can choose which elements of old buildings to copy and which not to copy; you can copy brickwork, window design and courtyard layouts without copying poor disabled access, ineffective climate control or impractical staircase layout.
- mirceal 9y agois it? I'm not saying you need one or the other. I'm saying that it's a spectrum and you have to chose what you optimize for. The most functional building is not going to be the most beautiful one and vice-versa.
- njarboe 9y agoThat is why one should hire a great architect. To try and get as much as possible of both with a given location and budget. With a bad one you can easliy get neither. See sites on bad McMansions.
- mirceal 9y agoAgree. And you can definitely get some of both. My original badly made point was that you cannot prioritize form over function and get away with it. Now that I think about it I guess the reverse is true (ie you cannot prioritize function over form and call it a day).