2 ms·
Everyone ignored the most important part of your question, which is "Why should Uber have disclosed this letter to Waymo?" They should have because in a civil
by gpm 9y ago
Everyone ignored the most important part of your question, which is "Why should Uber have disclosed this letter to Waymo?"
They should have because in a civil case like this there is a property called discovery where each side gets to request certain information from the other side. And the other side is required to give it or argue it's outside the bounds of what they can request to the judge, who will decide. In this case Uber had already legally agreed/been ordered to give Waymo all documents in categories this letter clearly falls under, in various ways. For instance one of the more damning given what we know about the letter would be "All DOCUMENTS REGARDING DEFENDANTS’ policies regarding employees’ use of personal computers or other devices while working at or for DEFENDANTS."
A lot is still redacted from the public, but you can see more details on page 7 of their brief: https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.308136/gov.uscourts.cand.308136.2281.3.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.308136...
I say this is the most important part of your question, because this is the one area where Uber pretty much unquestionably, intentionally broke the law. Regardless of whether or the allegations in the letter are true, it was a document that they were legally required to turn over but didn't. The head council explicitly made the decision to turn it over to the US attorney and not Waymo so it's not even plausible they missed it.
(I am not a lawyer)