3 ms·
Did Google rip Campfire off? Absolutely. Is Campfire "obvious"? Design always seems obvious in retrospect. That's the point of design, it isn't a whiz-bang new
by raganwald 19y ago
Did Google rip Campfire off? Absolutely.
Is Campfire "obvious"? Design always seems obvious in retrospect. That's the point of design, it isn't a whiz-bang new feature, it's a way to arrange existing things in an effective way. Good design is the art of doing things that--in retrospect--seem obvious.
In any event, i find it interesting that Google now appear indistinguishable from Microsoft. Copying somebody else's app and giving your copy away so you can drive traffic to your platform has been done before.
- michaelneale 19y agoWelcome to 2008. Please fasten your seatbelts, enjoy the range of free software on offer. Also, if your business involves software as a service, stay well out of the way of google ;)
- raganwald 19y agoNobody asked whetherthey should or would rip campfire off. The question is whether they did.
- michaelneale 19y agoyes... and?
- tptacek 19y agoThis isn't a Google application. It's a side project --- and, design aside, a totally obvious side project --- of a couple Google developers. Do you really want to single them out for attacking 37Signals? As for the non-obviousness of Campfire's design, defend the argument. When Campfire was launched, it wasn't launched as a pioneering new chat interface. I don't see what's particularly interesting about it.
- raganwald 19y agoGoogle launched and showed off an example application that rips Campfire's look and feel off. As for whether it was a "pioneering new chat interface," that is hardly the point where ripping off design is concerned. It's just like ripping off the layout and visual appearance of a designer's portfolio web site. There is nothing pioneering or innovative about the way designers make web sites to display their work, but there is design in the chocies they make and there is value in those choices. If design doesn't matter, Google could and should show a chat application with a completely different look. If design does matter, then they are executing a blatant rip off. Is it illegal? Wrong? Lame? You can decide for yourself. But it is still a rip off. update: This is my last word on the subject. But I will say the following: there is a very well-known standard of "obviousness": The Clean Room. Perhaps this application was made in a clean room, or something close enough: if the people making it weren't familiar with Campfire and arrived at almost the identical design from first principles, then of couse I am happy to withdraw my statement and accept that the design in "obvious." Perhaps they have already spoken up and assured the world that it is just a coincidence that their app is so similar to Campfire. But I am not convinced that a particular design is "obvious" if it is executed by someone who studied another design first.
- tptacek 19y agoThis is actually not what "clean room" means.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]