4 ms·
Had he gone off to live happily alone in the mountains as a Buddhist monk, he would've been similarly unproductive. I assume you would've found that more admira
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Had he gone off to live happily alone in the mountains as a Buddhist monk, he would've been similarly unproductive. I assume you would've found that more admirable
Yeah, I am done with this. In spite of me stating that this is not about moralizing, you keep projecting moral nonsense onto me.
The only thing I am talking about is this guy blew through a lot of money in a single weekend and this had long term negative repercussions for his entire life. He went back home to his parents and then never really cut the umbilical cord again. It interfered with his ability to live as he saw fit for many years afterwards and to this day. He threw away his one shot at ever getting to be an adult and live on his own terms.
To be perfectly clear, if he had blown through all that money for cocaine and sex workers, come back revitalized, stood up to his parents and said "Yeah, I don't care about your opinions about my life" and sold his second car to make it possible to keep his independence, I might well feel that was money well spent. But that isn't how it went down. Instead, he tucked tail, moved back home and then never lived down what an untrustworthy "loser" he was in the eyes of a lot of people whose opinions mattered to him.
Edit: Trying to stop using the F word like a substitute for very.
- vannevar 9y agoI meant no offense. I understand that the guy's story is a sad one, and that he could've spent the money more productively. He could've been a better person. None of that has anything to do with what happened to the money after he spent it, which was the point of my original comment. If the focus is on the guy and his behavior, and the money that comes in and out of his life, it says very little about how much that money is contributing to the economy. Like a lot of things, it's the economic network that matters, and his position in it, and not so much his direct marginal contribution to it (or lack thereof). If he had been terminated without any severance, he might've still moved back home and never lived it down. And the money would've taken some other path through the economy, maybe a more productive one, maybe a less productive one. Either way, it wouldn't be pissed anywhere, it would just travel a different path through the network.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI meant no offense Thank you. Money can be spent in a manner that is harmful, that actually reduces value in the world. It can also be genuinely lost or destroyed. But I don't imagine you and I will ever bridge whatever communication gap is happening here. So, I don't plan to "throw more good money after bad" in terms of investing more of my time in what feels like an inane discussion.
- vannevar 9y agoDon't give up, you're actually pretty close. Yes, it can be spent in a way that reduces value. And it can literally be destroyed (as I noted several times above). In the latter case, we agree it's been lost. But in the case where it's used to destroy value, the money itself still remains in the system, and might very well be used to create greater value than what was destroyed. For instance, a kid might buy a cherry bomb from another friend and destroy a mailbox. But the kid he gave the money to uses that money to start a business. The net value of the money's path through the cherry bomb to the business could be greater than if the first kid had donated it to a charity instead. My point is that while we can make a value judgment on the kid's spending, we can't say with certainty what the broader economic effect is. Even if he's spending all his money on sex workers, cocaine, and cherry bombs.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMy point is that while we can make a value judgment on the kid's spending, we can't say with certainty what the broader economic effect is. There is about a metric fuckton (TM) of data that shows that when people are handed a big check that they didn't work for, it typically gets spent differently than it would have been had it required blood, sweat and tears to get the exact same amount of money. And the way in which it gets spent differently is typically consumptive, usually with little or no long term value and potentially a lot of long term harm. This is a thing we can know with a fair degree of certainty. It is part of why the NFL tries to provide some kind of financial literacy for its players. Most of them will have a very short career in professional football. Probably most of the ones who aren't there very long will never make that kind of money again. They are trying to make sure that if some guy only make a quarter of a million dollars one year of his life, it pays for something of long term benefit, like a house or some retirement savings. Don't give up, you're actually pretty close. This suggests you are the smart, knowledgeable person here to educate my less smart, less knowledgeable self. I was describing a communication gap due to differing mental frameworks for the issue. I was not suggesting one of us was "dumber" than the other. I moderated a smarty pants email list at one time. I am all too familiar with the tendency for smart people to think they are smarter than the person they are talking to. That attitude is not constructive and it is not something I care to keep engaging with.