4 ms·
Here is a crazy interview trick that I've seen work well. Group interviews! It isn't as crazy as it sounds. Suppose that you're hiring for multiple related r
by btilly 9y ago
Here is a crazy interview trick that I've seen work well. Group interviews! It isn't as crazy as it sounds.
Suppose that you're hiring for multiple related roles. You have a bunch of people who are ready for their in-person interview come in as a group. You go to lunch with some select employees, and explain that they are not in competition with each other because you're hoping to make multiple hires. Then you come back and are asked to do a basic hackathon over the afternoon. (The available projects for which are all small but real stand-alone things that you could use.) Through the time, you take each person aside, ask them for a basic demonstration of ability, then return them to the group.
Hire all who seemed competent and worked well in the group.
This saves a lot of time over interviewing each one, and shows you something important about how they will be in the workplace that you otherwise wouldn't see in the normal interview structure. And it is more fun for the candidates!
- seanwilson 9y ago> And it is more fun for the candidates! Really? It would be difficult to shake the thought that you're being directly compared and in competition.
- booleandilemma 9y agoI participated in one of these group interviews recently and it felt like I was in the Hunger Games.
- btilly 9y agoThat can be a challenge for some. But it is more common to see people swapping phone numbers, leads, and tips. Looking for a job is an isolating experience. And you don't often get the chance to connect with people who are in the same boat as you. And for the people who really can't get past trying to compete against each other..would you want someone like that on your dev team? That's one of the things that this is intended to weed out.
- seanwilson 9y agoPersonally, I would hate preparing for a normal interviewing experience and be thrown into something completely nonstandard like this. Why would they be swapping tips and numbers if they're in competition with each other?
- smichel17 9y agoI've never done a group interview, so I'm speculating, but the concept sounds nice, so long as there is also sufficient 1-on-1 time. > I would hate preparing for a normal interviewing experience and be thrown into something completely nonstandard like this. Would it a problem if you told candidates they're doing group interviews? Might be a flaw in this particular variant, not the concept itself. > Why would they be swapping tips and numbers if they're in competition with each other? From the top level comment: "You [...] explain that they are not in competition with each other because you're hoping to make multiple hires."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- btilly 9y agoThat explanation is critical. If people can get into that mindset it all works. If not..it is a disaster.
- maxxxxx 9y agoYou'll filter for one or two extroverts that quickly dominate a group and the rest will just tag along.
- btilly 9y agoYou'll also notice the introvert that quietly builds a critical piece.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThat's pretty optimistic. I most likely would just check out.
- Double_a_92 9y agoYeah but you wouldn't hire them, because not working as a team mate. Just hire the one that spews out the most random ideas without thinking for a second first.
- jonathankoren 9y agoWhat makes you think the introvert will get a critical piece, instead of the least critical scraps?
- btilly 9y agoIt is the job of the interviewer to ask each person what they are working on, and what they think that they could do instead. If you're hiring multiple positions, you generally have the room to hire different roles. So it is in everyone's interest for people to do the kind of work that they think they are best at. If setting up this kind of group interview sounds too risky, you can do it more easily. Go to a startup weekend, look for people you'd want to hire. You get a similar environment and similar opportunity.
- jonathankoren 9y agoThis is highly dependent on group dynamics. I'm not at all convinced that the sexiest piece won't get grabbed by the most assertive person in the group, assuming of course that multiple people are attracted to the same piece.
- drharby 9y ago>fun I would like to see somw metrics
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoThis will go as well as all the "Group Discussions" that many companies conduct go (aka not well). You are expected to treat other interview candidates as your friends and peers while you all know you are competing with each other. But you can't show that, so you resort to fake over-niceties and all to look friendly and sociable. At the same time, everyone feels pressure to prove themselves over the others, so they will want to say something so that they appear intelligent and don't get lost in the background. Not everyone can do it equally well, so the more extroverted types will dominate and make the others feel like shit.