4 ms·
> 2) Protections for criminal defendants in the US are the greatest in the world: Other countries (such as Western Europe, Canada, Australia, New Zealand) have
by skissane 9y ago
> 2) Protections for criminal defendants in the US are the greatest in the world:
Other countries (such as Western Europe, Canada, Australia, New Zealand) have weaker protections for criminal defendants during the trial, yes. But, assuming you are convicted, prison sentences tend to be shorter on average and there is no death penalty. On another point, to compare Australia to the US, the High Court of Australia has basically full appellate jurisdiction (even on state law questions) when it chooses to exercise it, whereas the US Supreme Court's jurisdiction is limited to appeals on points of federal law only, and AEDPA has limited access to federal habeas corpus. So I think the convicted have greater rights of appeal under Australian law than US law. So it isn't clear to me that criminal defendants actually have more rights under the US system overall – they have more rights prior to conviction, but less rights afterward.
- marcoperaza 9y agoI don't see how the different jurisdictions of the high courts really plays into this. Everything in the Bill of Rights (with the exception of the right to jury trial in civil cases, recognized substantially by every state anyway) is applied to the states as a matter of federal law and is therefore subject to review by the federal Supreme Court. For things not implicating any federal question, why is having an appeal to the federal Supreme Court important? Having an extra layer of government does not grant you more rights in and of itself.
- skissane 9y agoFrom the criminal appellants viewpoint, it is in their interests to have as many opportunities to appeal and as many grounds to appeal as possible. The more opportunities to appeal, the greater chance that one of your appeals may turn out favourably to you. So, in the US system, you cannot appeal points of state law to federal courts, but in the Australian system you can, so you have more opportunities to appeal in Australia. Plus, AEDPA limits access to federal habeas corpus (which is a form of collateral appeal as opposed to direct appeal), whereas there is no corresponding limitation under Australian law. How does this to relate to rights? Well, arguably one of our rights is the right to appeal adverse judicial decisions. And the Australian legal system grants more extensive rights in that area than the US one does.
- dragonwriter 9y agoAnd, of course judicial process is the means by which other rights are given effect, so less appeal opportunities translates, the reliability of the individual courts being equal, to less effective protection of whatever rights exist on paper.
- marcoperaza 9y agoAgain, if a state law case implicates any federal issues, such as the Bill of Rights, then you can appeal to the US Supreme Court. For those not well-versed in law, this discussion is very misleading. Appellate courts do not retry facts, they only decide if there was an error of law in the lower court. American states retain a lot more power than Australian states do, including the right to their own common law and to apply their own judicial philosophy. To substitute the judgment of the federal courts on issues of purely state law is to abolish federalism to a large degree.
- skissane 9y ago> For those not well-versed in law, this discussion is very misleading. Appellate courts do not retry facts, they only decide if there was an error of law in the lower court. Appellate courts (at least in some systems) are allowed to reopen the facts, for example to consider new evidence not available at the time of trial - see e.g. http://www.courtofappealbc.ca/appellant-guidebook/3.5-introducing-new-evidence http://www.courtofappealbc.ca/appellant-guidebook/3.5-introd... > American states retain a lot more power than Australian states do, including the right to their own common law and to apply their own judicial philosophy. To substitute the judgment of the federal courts on issues of purely state law is to abolish federalism to a large degree. Australian state court systems have always been subject to review by higher courts. Originally by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, and now the High Court of Australia has taken over that jurisdiction. I don't think it is reasonable to say that because we do federalism differently than the US, we don't do federalism at all. It is also worth keeping in mind that there is a potential tension between states rights and individual rights. If a state is trying to limit my rights as an individual, and the federal government or courts wants to stop that, and "states rights" limit the ability of the federal government or courts to step in and protect my individual rights, then that is a case in which my individual rights are being sacrificed to protect "states rights". So, I'd say that in the matter of appeals, the US chooses to prioritise states rights over individual rights in a way in which Australia doesn't.