5 ms·
> You must run Ubuntu 16.04 LTS, Ubuntu 17.04, Ubuntu 17.10, Pop!_OS 17.10, or an Ubuntu derivative and have the System76 driver installed to receive the latest
by LeoPanthera 9y ago
> You must run Ubuntu 16.04 LTS, Ubuntu 17.04, Ubuntu 17.10, Pop!_OS 17.10, or an Ubuntu derivative and have the System76 driver installed to receive the latest firmware and disabled ME on laptops*
Ubuntu is the distribution that once sent everything you typed into the desktop search box to Amazon so that it could deliver you ads. Current versions may not do that but it's clear that Canonical prioritizes profit over privacy.
It's disappointing that if you choose not to run Ubuntu you can't take advantage of their firmware update tool.
- orblivion 9y agoBut, the very next line gives hope: > System76 will investigate producing a distro-agnostic command line firmware install tool. Follow us on your preferred social network for updates.
- djsumdog 9y agoYea I'm sure we'll see a more generic command. This was probably just to get things out the door, quickly, with the default operation systems they have installed. Keep in mind, testing this type of update is pretty important. I'm sure they went through this several times with multiple versions of all their hardware. Honestly for the sake of not bricking a laptop, I think they should release a bootable USB image for other Linux distros and operating systems. Flash it to a USB stick and now you have a completely stable environment, with the kernel you've tested against, and remove potential unknowns.
- ythn 9y agoSo? Install Ubuntu, receive updated firmware/disabled ME, reinstall distro of choice. Also: > System76 will investigate producing a distro-agnostic command line firmware install tool. Follow us on your preferred social network for updates.
- orblivion 9y ago> Install Ubuntu, receive updated firmware/disabled ME, reinstall distro of choice. For a single software update? With whatever else a normal human has going on in life? There's no way.
- dopeboy 9y agoI agree - that's too much work. Can this task be performed in a VM?
- barkingcat 9y agoThink about what you are asking first. A VM is a virtual machine that theoretically is separated from the base hardware. I don't think a VM is the solution for Bios Updates or changing bits on the physical hardware itself. Of course, you can monkeypatch the VM's bios all you want! But that would be erased the next time you start a new vm. The only other way is to find a security hole in KVM, qEMU, or XEN, and then exploit it to break out of the VM[1] and get access to base hardware. Hard to do, but it does happen. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_machine_escape https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_machine_escape
- icebraining 9y agoProbably not, but in a chroot it might.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- drbawb 9y ago> For a single software update? This isn't a software update, it's a firmware update. I don't expect updating firmware to be painless; and I'd rather it not be painless. Updating a PROM is a messy process fraught with peril, I want as many checks & balances between my clumsy fingers and that flash as possible. > With whatever else a normal human has going on in life? There's no way. Many vendors don't ship ELF binaries update their firmware at all, and yet I still manage to flash their devices. I've lost count of how many times I have to throw FreeDOS a USB drive to flash the RAID controllers I use. Putting Ubuntu on a flash drive to install a firmware update is hardly any more complicated than that. (At a minimum: at least you'll have a reasonably competent shell and functional networking w/ an Ubuntu live image.)
- rurban 9y agoNo need to install Ubuntu. Just load from a Ubuntu live DVD, install the driver, and so on...
- simcop2387 9y agoThis would be my way of handling it. I usually keep a usb stick around with ubuntu on it just because the live version of it is incredible useful as a tool.
- xxpor 9y agoI'm guessing it's really just a packaging issue. If you wanted, you could download/extract the deb and fix up the file paths and it would work.
- johncolanduoni 9y agoThere could also be issues with dependency versions of the executables that prevent cross-distro usage; it’s difficult to run the same executable on e.g. Ubuntu and Fedora unless it only depends on glibc. Even then you have to worry about glibc symbol versioning.
- xxpor 9y agoI haven't looked, is there no source available?
- wilun 9y ago> Even then you have to worry about glibc symbol versioning. Symbol versioning will actually permit the binary compat (unless you have a rather clueless approach), and not break it by some kind of "oh my god I don't know what is this black magic and I would rather not be bothered to learn anything about it even if it is my job to release binaries people can run, so let's just forever rant a little about symbol versioning and pretend GNU systems are hard to target". Now in order to release a binary which will work on multiple systems, obviously you can't rely on symbol versions that are only present on some of those systems but not all. If you intent to at least test it on those targets (and well, you... should? ) then obviously you have access to them and obtaining a toolchain on the "oldest" one is trivially an apt-get (or equivalent) away. Basically, if you want the simplest worryless solution that will work 99.9999% of the time: you build your binary there. Done. You might even be able to find some compilation flag or something like that if you insist on building on a recent distro, while still targeting old ones. I have not checked; I would if I had to do that.
- johncolanduoni 9y agoI was unable to find such a flag last time I had this issue. It’s not black magic, but most other platforms don’t require you to build on the oldest platform you support. That can be quite a pain if that version hasn’t backported newer versions of the tool chain you are using, requiring you to do a custom build of that instead of using the package manager. So not quite an apt-get away.
- oconnor663 9y ago> Current versions may not do that but it's clear that Canonical prioritizes profit over privacy. If we criticize people this strongly for things they've already fixed, how can we expect them to listen to us when we ask them to fix things?
- webkike 9y agoIf we don't criticize people for doing bad things they should never have done, how can we expect other people to not do those bad things in the first place?
- barsonme 9y agoIn perpetuity? Halfway serious question, fwiw.
- shabbyrobe 9y agoIt’s the way the wind is blowing. Even Firefox is infested with invasive, on-by-default telemetry now. The price of freedom from it is eternal vigilance. I’d very much prefer Canonical not to get it into their heads that it’s OK to do it again.
- ibotty 9y agoNot saying that telemetry should not be opt-in, but sending every keystroke to amazon and sending aggregated, anonymized data is not the same.
- mulmen 9y agoYes, in perpetuity. Don't betray your user's interests. It's a capital offense to your credibility. This isn't a riddle. Ubuntu may still be a good OS today and if so you should use it but that doesn't mean their previous actions didn't happen.
- unethical_ban 9y agoIt was always something people could turn off, and they were very open about the feature existing. This wasn't the cross-site ad tracking that's probably more severe on every website you go to.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- geofft 9y agoThis post is about System76 delivering firmware for System76 machines, which are shipped with either Ubuntu or Pop!_OS. I'm not really disappointed that a hardware manufacturer is releasing their firmware update tools for their supported OSes first. (If you are not running their hardware, this firmware update tool is presumably not for you, anyway.)
- zeveb 9y agoIf System76 would go with Debian stable, I'd be very strongly tempted to make them my supplier-for-life. As it is, I go with Zareason instead.
- leadingthenet 9y agoMate, what's stopping you from installing Debian on any of their systems?
- mykull 9y agoMy ~2011 motherboards BIOS lets you reflash it from INSIDE the BIOS, from a connected readable storage device, i.e. a flash drive. It eliminates any need for OS-specific update tools. I am surprised this isn't more common.
- jackpot51 9y agoThis simply does not scale. Every single customer has to download the BIOS, usually from a questionable source, plop it on an unreliable flash drive, and then boot into the setup menu to manually select the right file. Our method will automate most of this process more reliably.
- throw2016 9y agoFirefox does the exact same thing with Google and other search providers and gets significant revenue, and nobody accuses them of 'putting profit over privacy' Bit hypocritical to pan Ubuntu while giving Firefox a pass. At least for Ubuntu there are many alternatives. This was probably a misguided attempt by Canonical to generate some revenue, they recently had to lay off a significant number of employees. Criticism is valid but dismissing the entire Ubuntu project because of a single bad decision taken and reversed years ago is uncharitable and over the top.
- ibotty 9y agoWhich keystrokes does firefox send opt-out to google by default, to display ads? Don't spread FUD.
- throw2016 9y agoEvery single thing you type in the search bar is sent to Google or whoever they have done the search deal. Ubuntu used to do the exact same thing with Amazon, its an affiliate link and does not 'display ads', that is complete FUD. Please understand the issues before commenting. It's a search scope for amazon so you can get amazon search results in the unity search bar if desired. Firefox has also done a privacy busting ad deal with Cliqz where user's browsing history is sent to cliqz servers for targeted advertising. This is even worse for user privacy.