6 ms·
Even if they manage to kill their competition -- and I'm not expecting they will -- I don't understand what their endgame is. I don't see what their moat is. Ri
by wpietri 9y ago
Even if they manage to kill their competition -- and I'm not expecting they will -- I don't understand what their endgame is. I don't see what their moat is. Ridesharing companies are not hard or expensive to start. They'll have a hard time extracting monopoly rents, and there isn't much of an economy of scale they can reap.
And once autonomous cars become part of the picture, I think they're in an even worse position. Suddenly they're not competing just against would-be moguls. Now they're up against the car companies, who have strong brands, deep pockets, and the ability to make cars at cost. Imagine, for example, BMW extending their leasing business to on-demand car use. We also have existing car rental companies that will be eager to get in on the action. And that's not counting the zillion other outfits with strong brands and a taste for expansion. Apple, for example. Virgin. Amazon.
I just don't see how this ends well for them. At best, I think 10 years from now they'll be the next Groupon: the hot startup everybody everybody loved but now nobody talks much about and is trading at a fraction of their peak valuation.
- djsumdog 9y ago> Ridesharing companies are not hard or expensive to start. There is a lot of work that goes into the infrastructure behind companies like Uber and Lyft. You need good engineers that build products that are reliable and well tested, to work 24/7. It is a hard problem. A lot of the smaller city taxi companies that have apps contract to larger vendors as well.
- gaius 9y agoYou need good engineers that build products that are reliable and well tested, to work 24/7 So did newspapers - the very definition of mission-critical computing is the the paper HAS to hit the stands the next morning. Didn't save them from half-arsed competitors running glorified blogs...
- ams6110 9y agoThe backend systems can be SaaS. Amazon could do it. Anyone can then buy a local franchise for that backend service in their area. Or it could be offered whitelabel.
- wpietri 9y agoSure. But compare with Flywheel, which has less than 50 employees and produces a perfectly adequate app. Infrastructure is also much easier at small scales. And as you point out, this is pretty easy to outsource. That means that that Uber's engineers are not making much of a mote.
- gaius 9y agoBMW extending their leasing business to on-demand car use BMW has no choice but to do this, as do all the strong brands. They can't compete in a world that you don't care about the brand because you're riding journey-by-journey with no personal investment.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xbzbanna 9y agoOfferings like Uber Pool and Lyft Line are the future of the business and depend entirely on economies of scale. Putting multiple paying passengers in the car at once and reducing driver downtime completely changes the economics, but only if there is a high density of riders and drivers. Edit: There are two possible stories here about Uber and Lyft's losses, and we can't tell which is right from the outside. 1. Uber and Lyft are in a price war death spiral, heavily subsidizing all rides to compete. Their only hope is for all competitors to die, so they can take over the whole market and raise prices. Then vague hopes of lowering costs with self-driving tech and take the surplus as profit. The plan doesn't seem viable, since they have no moat and they can't outspend GM and other self-driving players. 2. Uber and Lyft can actually make a profit in mature markets, but choose to subsidize rides in growing markets, on the theory that growing the market size increases the long term profit opportunity. The data we need to evaluate this idea isn't public, however Uber did a "prove it" quarter in 2016 where they turned the spigots to be profitable in the US. They are now pursuing growth in the US again, expanding to a larger territory and expanding Pool and other offerings like flat-rate passes in mature cities. Under this model, Uber could at any time decide to become profitable, but the revenue growth would stop, placing a cap on the valuation. Notably, there is no "predatory pricing" here. With internal finances, we could easily tell whether option 2 is valid. You can bet Uber is constantly doing experiments on price elasticity of demand and knows exactly where the truth is. You can bet Softbank has seen numbers we have not. If Uber wants to IPO, I would expect them to provide additional public info, possibly pivoting to profitability again in the US. But doing a pivot like that permanently reduces the size of the opportunity, allowing Lyft to capture that new market instead, so they may be reluctant to do it large scale.
- jsonne 9y agoThe problem though is that they led the way by breaking down all the regulatory barrier to entries. Whats to stop anyone from starting a ridesharing company tomorrow?
- lev99 9y agoThe network effect. You have the give your drivers a reason to use your app instead of uber. You have to give riders a reason to use your app instead of uber. The two reasons have to be good enough to build a large enough network for the rideshare system to work.
- aaavl2821 9y agoor worse, the next webvan
- lsiq 9y agoThey do have a small moat in the short term; the network of drivers, brand recognition they've built up (even w/ the bad press), the large codebase they have by now, and the amount of capital to start such a business from scratch is not insignificant. However, you are right to bring up autonomous cars. I always thought it amusing that Kalanick et al were so anxious to bet the house on autonomous cars, when in fact, they are the company's greatest existential threat long-term. Once those cars are readily available and street-legal, there's nothing stopping Enterprise or Avis or the automakers themselves from becoming overnight competitors. And once drivers are taken out of the picture, ride prices will plummet. Margins will also thin because of the likely extreme competitiveness of this market. I would not want to be an Uber investor that's for sure. In theory, the "winner" will be whoever scales the most (i.e. has the most capital to put into their fleet) and has the most effective marketing. In practice, prices may be close enough that people will rent car X because they like brand/model Y better. If I were on Uber's board, I would advise against trying to win that war which they will lose once/if the automakers get in on it, and instead get creative about how to conquer the market in a more niche way. Someone is going to have to program self-driving ambulances :)
- ghaff 9y ago>And once drivers are taken out of the picture, ride prices will plummet. 1. This is probably further out than a lot of people assume. Reliable door to door fully autonomous in dense cities is one of the hardest use cases to solve but it's more or less what you need for self-driving taxis. 2. The pricing probably also won't "plummet." The IRS mileage rate (about 53 cents/mile) is probably a reasonable floor to use. That's still about half current Uber rates.
- robryan 9y agoElectric cars might do better on that mileage rate?
- jdmichal 9y agoThe IRS puts "variable costs" at about 14 cents per mile. So, yes they may do better, but not significantly better. Also, electric means either battery swaps or significantly longer refueling time. Not a problem for commuter cars with downtime anyway. But for a 24/7 business, that becomes more impactful. https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/2017-standard-mileage-rates-for-business-and-medical-and-moving-announced https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/2017-standard-mileage-rates-for... "The standard mileage rate for business is based on an annual study of the fixed and variable costs of operating an automobile. The rate for medical and moving purposes is based on the variable costs."