3 ms·
I thought a Faraday cage had to be grounded.
by cma 9y ago
I thought a Faraday cage had to be grounded.
- learc83 9y agoNo it doesn't. In practice they often are, but it's not necessary to block a signal from outside the cage.
- giobox 9y agoNo idea, but it’s pretty widely known even in high school physics that radio waves can often be blocked or interfered with conductive metals such as aluminium foil, hence the “tin foil hat” jokes, and the plastic/rubber antenna lines or windows on smartphones with metal enclosures.
- pishpash 9y agono? any charge structure completely surrounded by a conductor is indistinguishable from the outside. ground is an arbitrary reference.
- civilian 9y agoFrom the article: > Aluminum is not a great conductor—it heats up when a lot of power is pushed through it—so a snack bag would potentially melt if it was used to try to block a strong radio signal from inside. But the signals from GPS satellites are weak and can easily be interfered with, intentionally or not, in many ways. I imagine that if the twisties bag had been grounded, it would be even more resistant to melting if the signal had been too strong for it.
- asteli 9y agoWhat a load of nonsense. Aluminum is a great conductor of electricity. Not as good as copper, but good enough that it gets used as the conductor for high tension power transmission lines. Additionally, you’d need a far more powerful radio than a cellphone would contain to melt a plastic bag. A cellphone radio is what, 3W? You might threaten the bag if you focused all that energy in a dime sized spot on the bag, but a cell radio is intentionally a roughly isotropic radiator.