5 ms·
So what exactly is your solution? What law do you put in place, precisely? Google has to provide consumers with whatever information they want, whenever they wa
by fastball 9y ago
So what exactly is your solution? What law do you put in place, precisely? Google has to provide consumers with whatever information they want, whenever they want it, free of charge? Because that seems to be what you're gunning for.
- coldtea 9y ago>So what exactly is your solution? What law do you put in place, precisely? Forced (inter-)nationalization of Google under the control of the UN. >Google has to provide consumers with whatever information they want, whenever they want it, free of charge? Pretty much yes. Charges should be bared by the Global Federation of Essential Services.
- fastball 9y agoYou're going to nationalize Google before nationalizing the internet itself? I think you're missing the forest for the trees.
- rusk 9y agoI think he means globalize rather than nationalize ... I guess someone's been reading Picketty ..
- jrs95 9y agoI never have, but if this is something he considers a good idea I think I'm going to have to just to understand what idiotic crap to expect in the next few decades
- rusk 9y agoadmit that the waters around you have grown And accept it that soon you'll be drenched to the bone If your time to you is worth savin' Then you better start swimmin' or you'll sink like a stone
- coldtea 9y agoSure, but then again Google is like 30% of the internet (if not more in traffic, if we add YouTube in the mix). And even more important than 30% perhaps, culturally, business-wise, etc.
- pc86 9y agoI can't even put into words how shockingly bad this "idea" is.
- jrs95 9y agoI didn't think there was a way for Bing to become a better search engine than Google, but I think this would do it.
- coldtea 9y agoYeah, government funded work only gave us the internet and the web after all.
- joshuamorton 9y ago(am Googler, am amused by this idea, so let's run with it) Would this apply to all of google, or just specific product areas (ie, would you only nationalize Search, or Search & Ads, or something else)? If yes, do tensorflow development now fall under the purview of the UN? Is Android now a partially closed-source, world-government administered, operating system, used by a significant fraction of every human being? If not, how does one manage infrastructure for the now government administered search system, and corporate everything-else? Do they share the datacenters (and thus give government employees access to the datacenters full of user data), or do they split the datacenters up somehow, and give some to the government, and keep others? What happens to my existing Google Account? Does the government get access to any of my user data, and if so, which subset? Do we do away with search personalization, or start it over from scratch? I'm very honestly curious how you would orchestrate this, or expect it to work.
- coldtea 9y ago>Would this apply to all of google, or just specific product areas (ie, would you only nationalize Search, or Search & Ads, or something else)? Mostly search. We'll drop the ads. People will be subsidising search already, so no need for ads. >If yes, do tensorflow development now fall under the purview of the UN? No, that Alphabet can keep. >Is Android now a partially closed-source, world-government administered, operating system, used by a significant fraction of every human being? Yes. >If not, how does one manage infrastructure for the now government administered search system, and corporate everything-else? Do they share the datacenters (and thus give government employees access to the datacenters full of user data), or do they split the datacenters up somehow, and give some to the government, and keep others? Every piece of data will be queryable by a simple RESTful API for everybody, including everybody's else search history. We'll call it "radical transparency". This is include the data of government members. >What happens to my existing Google Account? It remains as is, only better. >Does the government get access to any of my user data, and if so, which subset? Yes, all, see above. >Do we do away with search personalization, or start it over from scratch? We kill that. It never worked well anyway. I'm partly joking, and partly imagining what a sane humanity, that could build and coordinate stuff on a global scale without letting them to the markets, in other words a "Star Trek" like government, would do.
- tedunangst 9y agoSo what happens when another company makes a search engine that's better than UN Search and users switch to that? Does the UN just eat them up too? Round and round? Or do we make everybody sign a Search Antiproliferation Treaty that bans private search engines?
- mattmanser 9y agoIdentifying a problem caused by a monopoly is not the same as having to provide a solution for it. Some sort of regulation. No-one said they had to do it free.
- fastball 9y agoSo it would be ok with you if Google said "we exclude any search results we want, you can pay for Google premium to have uncensored results"?
- rusk 9y agoThat would actually be okay for me. But it wouldn't be okay for google as it would directly affect their revenue model of using traffic analysis as a means to promote advertising. There's probably more money in it for them that way. But Google's right to make money doesn't trump all other rights.
- mmrezaie 9y agoWell said, making us pay them for the quality/uncensored search results basically destroys the main source of how they can create insights on data by letting people use their services for free. Google's search business is now a public utility but so far I do not see regulatory systems capable of regulating it without destroying it (catch 22 so far).
- ksec 9y agoWhy am I reading a lot of these argument like being a left or right debate. I dont think Google is quite there yet to be regulated. You have alternative like bing, and you have Duck Duck Go, and the latter actually provide pretty decent results.
- rusk 9y agoThe discussion is more one of he principle of whether a dominant market leader is allowed to use its position of dominance in the market to influence that market or not. It’s hardly “left and right” to debate this as being right or wrong.
- rusk 9y ago> Google has to provide consumers with whatever information they want, whenever they want it, free of charge Sigh - anybody remember when this was pretty much a given?
- lumisota 9y agoFor the most part, no new law needs to be put in place. Anti-trust legislation should protect consumers from these practices.
- cjcole 9y agoWhen they, by virtue of their overwhelming market share, nuke a competitor's product off the face of the internet, whether algorithmically or intentionally, it feels reasonable to me to compel them to provide more detail than "we fixed the glitch". Google does not have the right to avoid being regulated in the public interest.
- rusk 9y agoNot only that, but there is an implicit contract with the public, that they provide a fair and balanced search of the web. If that's not the case then you're in anti-trust land.
- at-fates-hands 9y agoWhich is where they've been for years. It's one thing to talk about anti-trust. It's a completely different thing when you're on the same team as the government that would be bringing the case against you.
- fastball 9y agoYes, but you should address the root of the problem, not all the little symptoms. The issue isn't "Google has the power and occasional reason to remove search results"... the issue is "Google is so big/dominant that when they remove a single result it can have a huge impact". If anti-trust is your concern, make Google smaller. Regulate what % of marketshare they are allowed to control. Don't allow them to purchase any more competitors. Do things that are actual anti-trust prevention. Saying that the solution is to regulate all these little edge cases is ineffective and inefficient, because you need a different regulation for each concern that are all rooted in the same sentiment: Google is too big.
- wfo 9y ago>If anti-trust is your concern, make Google smaller. Regulate what % of marketshare they are allowed to control. Don't allow them to purchase any more competitors. This is one method, but the massive natural monopoly over search and 'gateway to the Internet' isn't something that is particularly well served by market competition, as we can see here. If we break up google, another monopoly will develop. If we prevent monopolies from developing through strict marketshare percentages, companies will hover at the brink of these %s and lobby and bribe politicians to remove the rules. Which is what they have just done in other media markets, recently. So long as you allow the organizations to be driven by private profit, you will have to struggle against the natural market impulse for every company to exert absolute dictatorial control over as much as possible and expand its power, every moment, every year, every election, at all costs. You should address the root of the problem (capitalism) not all the little symptoms. Require that companies that provide these public goods be run democratically, transparently by their workers as a public co-op. Nationalize them and make them all open source. There are other solutions.
- ptero 9y agoI am pretty sure Google derives a lot of its revenue from advertisers who operate on the assumption that the users see Google searches as mostly efficient and impartial. There can be special cases, but they should not be statistically significant. Thus it is in Google's own interest to keep providing efficient, unbiased search or at least the appearance of it. Break this and the customers will flee to other search engines and advertisers will follow. So yes, I expect Google to provide information to consumers free of charge as this is a key part of its business model. Which, however, has nothing to do with the article's point -- disappearance of a single entry with competitive advantage over Google. No statistical significance for search, but instead wielding its enormous power to squelch a small competitor. IMO, if true, this is the case for the government to address via rulemaking, courts or some other means.
- zbentley 9y agoI don't think advertisers care about the impartiality of the results, so long as their ads are getting eyeballs/clicks. An advertiser might care if there were another, more impartial search engine that was drawing those eyeballs away, but that seems vanishingly unlikely given the current ubiquity of Google as a household name and company. Sure, DuckDuckGo or whatever might draw some of the more tech-literate or paranoid crowd if Google started aggressively filtering results (which, for the record, I don't think they are doing or are likely to do), but why would advertisers care? Those people represent a tiny fraction of their eyeballs, perhaps so small as to be lost in statistical noise. Besides, many/most of the tech-literate folks use adblockers anyway, and the paranoids probably don't want to transmit their personal information online to buy things.
- mcguire 9y agoI'm sorry, are you arguing that it is all right for Google to abuse it's monopoly position because it is a monopoly? At least, from the advertiser's position?
- zbentley 9y agoI'm not making an argument about the rightness of any action. GP suggested that there exist > ...advertisers who operate on the assumption that the users see Google searches as mostly efficient and impartial. I do not believe that is factually accurate. I think advertisers don't have a compelling reason to care whether or not searches are impartial for the reasons I expressed.
- kingmanaz 9y ago> So what exactly is your solution? Enforce antitrust laws.