4 ms·
I'd guess the comment about HDCP is onto something. To build a KVM switch that works with modern displays without weird errors, it probably has to be an active
by xg15 9y ago
I'd guess the comment about HDCP is onto something. To build a KVM switch that works with modern displays without weird errors, it probably has to be an active HDMI/HDCP endpoint on its own - which means a vendor would either need to get its own sets of keys and do additional work to enforce all DRM restrictions - or they'd have to use leaked keys and prepare to get sued in an instant.
Even without HDCP, I remember another article explaining that it's already difficult enough to get two arbitrary HDMI devices to talk to each other because HDMI allows so many different modes of operation. I imagine the situation would get even worse if you had to negotiate common protocols for three endpoints at the same time.
- beojan 9y agoWhat if it physically unplugged the HDMI connection, and reconnected it to the other device? It wouldn't be quite as seamless since the initialization process would be repeated, but it would work.
- blauditore 9y agoNot even physically, but just redirecting the raw signal to another device should work. Maybe artificially break it for a second or so to better simulate plugging out and back in. I can't see how the actual endpoints could tell a difference between that and manually un- and re-plugging into a different device.
- beojan 9y agoThat's what I meant. Electrically, it's identically to unplugging from one device and plugging into the other.
- ztjio 9y agoThis is doable but unappealing as the OS will see the display is gone, and relayout the desktop environment every time you switch. Depending on your OS, and your personal concerns about all your environment behaviors, you might not care. I know I would be very annoyed by this.
- bonzini 9y agoYou'd need the HDCP master key, but you need not be a full-featured endpoint. See https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=2117 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=2117 for an example of a device that mixes an incoming HDMI video with a (non-HDMI) overlay video. The device is sold in the US, so it must be considered legal.
- gambiting 9y agoHDCP seems to work absolutely fine with the plethora of HDMI switches available on the market right now, so that can't be the issue.