3 ms·
Hard to say in 2017 :/ I'm of the opinion that the US is irretrievably lost in the hole of plutocracy / oligarchy. Recall during the election Donald Trump brag
by komali2 9y ago
Hard to say in 2017 :/
I'm of the opinion that the US is irretrievably lost in the hole of plutocracy / oligarchy. Recall during the election Donald Trump bragging he can buy politicians [1].
I'm finding "hero politicians" to be less and less common, and dare they raise their head, the establishment usually does everything in their power to mow the lawn. See - Bernie Sanders, alongside a couple other rare US Federal politicans, an actual good egg that appears to not be bought and paid for by corporate lobbyists.
There's lots of people trying to paint in black in white how obvious it is you can pay a politician to pass laws to protect you - we can go on for hours about Big Telecom minging about in local jurisdictions to prevent new providers, Big Oil essentially preventing a nuclear revolution in the USA, etc, but this site[2] paints a pretty clear picture in my opinion: Given that a corporation is expected to generate profit on dollars spent, why would BlueCross BlueShield and UnitedHealthcare be dumping money onto politicians? What reason could there possibly be other than to protect their profits?
I dunno man, other people are better than espousing the problem of money in politics than me, I just am cynical as hell after seeing time and time again obviously anti-WeThePeople votes bought for mere thousands.
So, to answer your question, in my un-professional opinion, the reason these hearings are good is they can inform the media and general public. They can get something on the record. We still reference hearings from decades ago - and can use that to apply pressure. "Senator, weren't you in x hearing, why then did you not do anything about y?" It can also inform the select few Hero politicians who can actually do good work for us with this new information - they're busy as fuck and this is one hell of a way to get data to them.
Ancillaries include giving new ammunition to Word Wars - various politicians can use buzzlines from the hearing to further their own goal, which might help us, might not, god only knows.
So my opinion, I'm glad these happen, but I think afterwards it'd be cool if people like Troy Hunt used their position to drum up donations to buy a couple of the politicians in the hearing, or at the very least throw more money at Twitter so that the Comcast and BroadBandForAmerica lobbyist propaganda promoted tweets can be buried under pro-WeThePeople material.
[1](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-bragged-that-his-money-bought-off-politicians-just-not-this-time/2016/09/07/00a9d1e4-750b-11e6-be4f-3f42f2e5a49e_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-bragged-that-h...)
[2](https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/issuesum.php?id=HCR&year=2017 https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/issuesum.php?id=HCR&year=2...)
- iiiete22 9y agoYou are right to point out the extent of how corrupt our political system is. It's understandable that you've become cynical after all this. But I hope your cynicism doesn't discourage you from trying to make things better. The corruption is allowed to exist because so many people, who should be outraged, simply throw up their hands and say that nothing can be changed. Troy is doing what he can to make a difference. We shouldn't have unrealistic expectations of what this can accomplish. But we should applaud the effort. We can force companies and governments to change their approach to security. But we need to start talking about these issues outside of HN. We need to get organized. We need to force change in our own companies.
- komali2 9y agoI feel you. I do my part, writing my congressfolks, kicking up shitstorms in their voicemails occasionally. My end-game though is to become Really Goddamned Rich and start swinging my big cash dick around. I'm kind of curious why folks like Musk don't do that more often. Gates did it once and nearly irradiated an entire species of virus (polio). EDIT: Btw, this is a great tool for pestering all your reps at once: https://democracy.io/#!/ https://democracy.io/#!/