3 ms·
We are a nation of contradictions. On the one hand we're puritanistic when it comes to sex and relationships (VP won't dine with opposite sex if not accompanie
by mc32 9y ago
We are a nation of contradictions.
On the one hand we're puritanistic when it comes to sex and relationships (VP won't dine with opposite sex if not accompanied), while at the same time exalting sexual revolution, freedom of association, etc. But we want to control how people behave at work in a proscripted manner.
It's like we can't decide what we want.
Obviously harassment is detrimental to the affected, but also, we should not be told to shy away from forming relationships at work. People spend upwards of third of their lives at work. It makes little sense to deny that to people out of hand.
That said, clear directives about abuse and harassment are necessary so people can work in an exclusive environment where they feel welcome.
- rayiner 9y agoIt’s not a contradiction. Our Puritanism is reflected in the extreme value we assign to work. Our feminist movement is no less Puritan—that’s why Hilary Clinton is so exalted for her professional accomplishments. Feminism thus means removing the barriers that women have to maximizing their success at work. Discouraging relationships at work serves that important end. Moreover, it seems that most of the voices demanding the right to inflict romantic overtures on coworkers are comin from men. I’ve never heard a professional woman say “you know, what I really want is for more guys to ask me out at work!”
- bitL 9y agoIt's absolutely naïve to think women aren't playing power games to get what they want as well; I see it daily with my sister that is a head of some law agency. She's single as there are few men above her that would date her and her romantic relationships are just for fun, often with (current/former) subordinates (IMO they are co-dependents that need a strong woman to feel good about themselves). There is zero backlash she is getting for that. She's not in the US though.
- rayiner 9y agoDoesn't that just reinforce my point? To the extent there are women "playing power games" that's not something the company should tolerate either. And just because the subordinate is consenting or even willful doesn't make dating a subordinate okay. Then it becomes a question of whether the supervisor can maintain objectivity and fairness with respect to the rest of the team.
- bitL 9y agoI agree, I'd absolutely love to live in such an environment. But my outlook is pessimistic towards abuse on both sides when one can get something out of it, while yours is optimistic. I'd worked in a company where a woman slept with a boss of a company offering a multi-million business opportunity and after securing the contract, she was rewarded with the role of a head of an important branch (I left in disgust with overall culture anyway). If you think this is an exception you might be surprised what a cesspool the top level of companies often is and what it takes to get there. The rules are applied highly selectively, often exploiting stupidity/idealism of the one that is now "out" that didn't properly cover their back or didn't play nasty politics collecting evidence against anyone that might threaten them. The flawless ones often aren't promoted either as there is no way to easily coerce them. In limit only the worst kind of people would stay in power unless some disaster comes, cleaning the Augean stables.
- mc32 9y agoPersonally, I'd stay away from work relationships because if they sour, then you're stuck working with someone you may not get along with... But that's my personal PoV. I don't see why I'd impose my preference on others, when coworkers hooking up is as natural as coed students hooking up in university. The one thing id agree upon is people needing to be behaved, and if they can't, ie, engage in harassment, then we should have strong structures to handle those cases.