4 ms·
Or, the deficit created by people who believed financial instruments of service economy is a better route ahead than genuinely productive society.
by varjag 16y ago
Or, the deficit created by people who believed financial instruments of service economy is a better route ahead than genuinely productive society.
- gaius 16y agoWhat are you talking about? The structural deficit in its present form existed prior to 2008, therefore anyone who says it was caused by the bank bailout is trying to pull the wool over your eyes. What was the deficit in 1997?
- varjag 16y agoReliance on the finance sector existed before 2008, how that contradicts what I say?
- gaius 16y agoOh I see, you are asserting that services aren't "real" economic activity. That's not actually true. It is true that the financial services sector accounts for a higher proportion of our economy than it does in other EU countries (still less than 10%). But it's also true that it is far more diverse than just subprime mortgages, and also true that most of its revenues are earned overseas.
- varjag 16y agoSorry for not being clear enough. No, services are indeed an economic activity. Just that I don't see service reliant economies as sustainable in the long term. They are all in debt, and always were working into debt, unlike traditional industrial societies, which have better track record. And along those lines, it is unfair to complain about high degree of welfare dependency: not everyone can work in the City, and there's only so much pipework to be fixed for plumbers.
- gaius 16y agoOh, I wasn't talking about welfare dependency, but about the public sector. New Labour added a million people to the payroll; they aren't all nurses and firemen. Similarly vastly expanded higher education with degree courses that proved to be useless in the job market.
- confuzatron 16y agoI'm afraid I don't see where you have successfully linked service-reliant economies with debt. There may be a correlation - I haven't looked at the data, but is A a cause of B?
- varjag 16y agoI've seen no half-decent model of wealth creation in service economies. It's the equivalent of dark matter in modern economics, and all attempts at it I've seen end up in explaining away why the accumulating debt is not an issue. If you know of a good one, please point me to it. I would like to be proven wrong here, and educate myself. Service economy sounds wrong superficially, and doesn't have clear, satisfactory explanation when you dig into details either. I feel the major reason why it is cited as future is that it's the way society drifts to at the moment. That, coupled with their actual underperformance, is what pushes me to this, apparently unpopular, conclusion.
- confuzatron 16y agoOK, it appears that we both lack any argument to back up our positions, but my position is 'Hmmm. I don't know about that'. I feel like I'm more justified in taking my position than you are in taking yours. :)