3 ms·
And all of the blame for this inconvenient atmosphere lies squarely with the harassers. So direct it at them, not the victims. As long as Trump and Moore and ev
by DonHopkins 9y ago
And all of the blame for this inconvenient atmosphere lies squarely with the harassers. So direct it at them, not the victims. As long as Trump and Moore and everyone on down are immune to these accusations, everybody else is just going to have to suck it up.
- bitL 9y agoIt doesn't change the outcome - a few that poison the well for everyone. Regardless of where the blame lies, everybody would suffer. In Andy's case it's not even clear if he indeed was a harasser or just played favorites/had a perceived bias towards his subordinate girlfriend that was not liked by other women in his team.
- harryh 9y agoBoth of the cases you describe in your "not even clear" are problems. If it was either of those things then it would demonstrate that Rubin was acting irresponsibly as a leader.
- bitL 9y agoNot sure if they deserve the same treatment as if he were a harasser though; it's a disproportional justice. I hate when bosses play favorites, but don't demand them to be kicked out of the company for that, as everyone is biased towards people they like, and many people make a career out of "hacking" their bosses.
- coldtea 9y ago>And all of the blame for this inconvenient atmosphere lies squarely with the harassers. So direct it at them, not the victims. If what 1/Nth of a group (the harassers) do, is applied to "all men" or "all VCs" or wharever, and are all "presumed guilty" then you can also blame those doing that lousy extrapolation. The idea that "all X are Y", is of the same nature as the racist notion that "all blacks are criminals" because they know of some black criminals.
- dguaraglia 9y agoNotice that the comment mentioned harassers not "men", so maybe you are jumping the gun a bit there. The idea that "all harassers are harassers" sounds pretty solid reasoning to me.
- coldtea 9y ago>Notice that the comment mentioned harassers not "men", so maybe you are jumping the gun a bit there I'm not discussing the parent comment itself (that would be extremely narrow focused). I'm answering the ideas expressed in the comment, based on the general context, and how we've seen things play out in the world.
- dguaraglia 9y agoSo you are making a general argument on the toxic role such generalizations have? ;) I understand where you are coming from, but I feel like jumping to conclusions about anything related to this story is way too soon.
- coldtea 9y ago>So you are making a general argument on the toxic role such generalizations have? ;) Yes, on the toxic role SUCH (not ALL) generalizations have. So no need for sarcasm ;) (Generalization, I'd say, is both the start point of knowledge, and the start (or maybe end?) point of prejudice. It's a tool. If it's not representative, or if it's representative but misreads the causes why it is so -- e.g. "blacks are overrepresented in jails because they're an inferior race with crime in their dna", it's harmful. Otherwise, it allows us to use abstractions, which elevate our thinking just like a higher level programming language does).